Papa Johns Pizza - Shelbyville

On this homepage, you can find the complete menu of Papa Johns Pizza from Shelbyville. Currently, there are 3 menus and drinks up for grabs. For seasonal or weekly deals, please contact the restaurant owner directly. You can also contact them through their website.

What User likes about Papa Johns Pizza:
My fiancée had problems ordering online, but I only had a cheeseburger pizza (better than Dominos! So I stopped on my way home from work. They were so helpful, friendly and efficient. I love this Papa John is here in Shelbyville. And of course, I want Gregory, the blonde woman in the pink hoodie, young woman in the white hoodie and the delivery driver who helped me all! Thank you very much!!!! View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about Papa Johns Pizza:
3-1-22, ~8pm pay attention to what people order online! 1/3 of our last order was on the stand. the last job had little cheese, so this time I ordered extra cheese to help for the last one that was missing. I also ordered light sauce, and it came out of every piece oozing! I literally have to squeeze sauce from my pizza to eat it. we also ordered medien, and they came small and partly dry. I have eaten this pizza for many years, and this is nothing I expect from papa john’s. we will not be back long, and hopefully they will hire someone who can actually make a real papa johns pizza!.