Fratellis Italian Eatery - Town of Brookhaven

The menu of Fratellis Italian Eatery from Town of Brookhaven includes 261 meals. On average, meals or drinks on the card cost about $7.6. The categories can be viewed on the menu below.

What Kyle O likes about Fratellis Italian Eatery:
Pros: Calzones and Strombolis are awesome, especially the chicken/bacon/ranch one. Definitely worth ordering again (and we have). Pizza is a pro too, very traditional NY style; haven't tried their other types (Grandmas/Sicilian) but will. They will do curbside as well if you ask nicely. Cons: With COVID, they are a bit on the slow side, so order ahead and be patient, it is a pandemic after all. A bit pricey for a qui... View all feedback.

What Pamela C doesn't like about Fratellis Italian Eatery:
My husband went in there last night and got a sandwich for himself and the not so classic Caesar salad for me. The sandwich was good, albeit on the small side. And my salad would have been great had it come with dressing. Which they obviously forgot. We didn 't realize this until he got home, then had to go out again for dressing. That kind of mistakes should not happen. That 's what happens when we stray from the fa... View all feedback.