Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Cara Mia:
I had an amazing dining experience at Casa Mia in Seaford with a group of seven! The cozy ambiance set the perfect tone for our gathering, and our waitress, Alexia, was outstanding—attentive and genuinely caring throughout the evening. The menu features delicious Italian dishes; the pasta with spicy sauces was a standout, and the seafood was fresh and flavorful. Everyone enjoyed their meals, and don’t miss the Tartuf... View all feedback.
What Steven Marterer doesn't like about Cara Mia:
Food was good but the meatballs were tasteless. They were moist but had not even a hint of garlic or cheese flavor. In fact, it seemed to me they were kept in warm water to possibly keep them moist since that was the texture and I know a local pizzeria that used to do that also so they were able to make their meatball hero’s instantly while smothering them in tomato sauce…. I hope they don’t do this but that is exact... View all feedback.
Always delicious ! The cavatelli and broccoli rabe egg rolls! So good !
Will never not order from here all the food is beyond delicious super consistent and have never had a problem 10/10
Lunch was a 2 star experience. The inflated 4.5 star rating is simply inaccurate. Spaghetti and meatballs was really disappointing like ragu out of the jar with overly breaded meatballs. Nothing good to say about it. Chicken marsala also no taste, sauce overly sweet. No way these dishes were prepared by an Italian chef. Bread was good, Caesar salad was good. You can do as good or better with take out from a pizza place.
Great celebration at Cara Mia of Seaford! Family birthday celebration with out standing service and the most tasteful delicious meals conveniently located on Merrick Road. Community minded Family owned/operated. We have had many dinners, attended Business meetings celebrations within this restaurant, which is quiet and is the perfect family setting.
I've been here a few times and every time I go it gets better! They don't take reservations so my group of 8 went at 5 PM on a Saturday and didn't have an issue getting seated, but by 5:30/6, every table was taken. We got a few apps which included mozzarella sticks, calamari, zucc sticks. For the main meal I got eggplant rollatini which was SOOOOO GOOD which came with a side of any pasta I wanted. I had leftovers for the next day. Staff is friendly and atmosphere is clean! Thanks!
Full Menu
Vegetarian
Pasta
Meat Dishes From The Pan
More information
QR-code link to the menu
