Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about I Love New York Pizza Of Route 4:
We have always enjoyed almost everything we have ordered from this restaurant, especially the Eggplant subs which were phenomenal. However, they have recently changed their preparation method. Instead of stacking the Eggplant like they used to, they now cut a slice down the middle and place the Eggplant inside, resulting in more bread than filling. Although this is a common method for making subs, we preferred their... View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about I Love New York Pizza Of Route 4:
I used to love ordering from this restaurant, but recently the driver was very rude when we questioned why he overcharged us for tips. He got angry and refused to deliver our pizza the next time we ordered. View all feedback.
The best pizza I ever had. the fastest delivery and service. my pizza always warm and tasty. Thank you!
If you like mice running around a place while your slice is being made, then this is a place for you. Good luck!
We ordered two Italian mixed subs. No tomatoes or onions on either sub. Mostly bread and lettuce, took meat and cheese from whole sub to make half a sub. When I called to complain I was told there was tomatoes and onions on both, despite the fact that we had just eaten them. The person I spoke with hung up on me. Their pizza is good, but stay away from the subs. I gave it one star NOT four
Could not even order becuase dude on the phone was so rude thanks alot
The roast beef sub and the capicola sub was lucky if it had 4 pieces of neat on it. The sub rolls were not very fresh. The onion rings were soggy with no flavor. The tomatoes on the subs were chunks instead of tomato slices. The lettuce didn't seem very fresh either. Prices were reasonable delivery driver was friendly and food got to us at a reasonable time frame. Just the quantity and quality were much less than expected.
Full Menu
Snacks
Starters & Salads
Salads
Side Dishes
More information
QR-code link to the menu
