Petonito's Pastry Cupcake Shoppe - East Haven

The average evaluation for Petonito's Pastry Cupcake Shoppe is 4.4, which means that the guests have a very high opinion of this place, Furthermore, this eatery is known as one of the best in East Haven, within the popular category Cafés.

What User likes about Petonito's Pastry Cupcake Shoppe:
We ordered my mother's birthday cake from Petonito this year, and they did an absolutely fantastic job! She asked a chocolate cake with strawberry mousse and whipped cream, which had a St. Patrick's Day theme, and I was blown away when I saw that the cake came out. Thank you for making your birthday so special! I couldn't help but pick up some zeppole and cannoli while I was there, and I was impressed that the Cannol... View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about Petonito's Pastry Cupcake Shoppe:
I wouldn't even give them one star, but this is not an option. I always like to give places a second chance. Since Petonito's has been taken over by new owners the pastries have not been the same. Twice now i have gone and i have gotten stale and raw pastries specifically the Sfogliatella and pasticiotti. The cookies also taste different, but not as good for sure.... I'm heading to Lucibello's, it's sad that Mark Pet... View all feedback.