Full menu with prices & pictures
The Gatsby 712 Main Street, Islip, 11751, Unite...
A comprehensive menu of The Gatsby from Islip covering all 9 courses and drinks can be found here on the food list. For changing offers, please get in touch via phone or use the contact details provided on the website.
The The Gatsby is indeed a good choice, which is also seen by the previous guests with an average assessment of 3.
What Jo Ann Falletta likes about The Gatsby:
A historic mansion with several different dining rooms and bar. The atmosphere is very comfortable and classy but not over the top. The calamari was mouth watering the best I 've had in a very long time. Salads are unique and delicious. The Rib eye steak was cooked to perfection with delicious flavor! Definitely worth the trip. View all feedback.
They have your typical Italian food which was good but nothing amazing. I had the potato gnocch...
A historic mansion with several different dining rooms and bar. The atmosphere is very comforta...