Mary's Pizza And Pasta - Islip Terrace

In the category Pizza, this place is rated as one of the best in Islip Terrace, and based on the average rating of 4.5, it's likely one of the favorite restaurants of its customers.

What User likes about Mary's Pizza And Pasta:
I’ve been to Mary’s in Speonk and Islip Terrace on several occasions. In my opinion, service and food is far superior in Speonk and worth the drive. The Speonk location has a nicer atmosphere and the service staff are very professional and competent. I found ordering the same meal at both locations that the Speonk location was superior, again, in my opinion and my experience. I enjoy a dinner at Marys but hands down... View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about Mary's Pizza And Pasta:
I usually buy lasagna here is always good but today I craved for it again I ordered one and instead of meet lasagna I just got cottage cheese and sauce limited meat. Maybe there is a new cook. If you read this put some meat on the lasagna unless I ask otherwise thank you I chose not to add a photo to save you the embarrassment The food here is great. It’s probably one of those one time things don’t let this discourag... View all feedback.