Full menu with prices & pictures
Ice Cream Cottage 1590 Montauk Hwy, 11950, Mastic, Uni...
(+1)6313953580
(+1)6316576334
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Ice Cream Cottage
The menu of Ice Cream Cottage from Mastic includes 45 dishes. On average, dishes or drinks on the menu cost about $21.7. The categories can be viewed on the menu below.
Tucked away in an appealing locale, this ice cream shop is a nostalgic treasure boasting an impressive variety of flavors and toppings. Patrons rave about the quality of the ice cream, including standout options like gelato and unique flavor combinations. However, the service has faced criticism recently for being sluggish and inattentive, creating a crowded and uncomfortable atmosphere. While the prices are considered slightly high, many agree that the artisanal quality justifies the expense. Overall, this establishment remains a beloved destination for those seeking delicious treats, though future improvements in customer service are essential for returning loyal visitors.
What User likes about Ice Cream Cottage:
long live ice cream cottage! best ice, best people, best memories! also some popping rainbow cake! it is not too expensive, but also not cheap, but the quality shows! my personal favorite is the cherry chip! at some point I never had in this whole land cherry chip. seriously, the parking sucks, and the line is long, but it's always worth the end! View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Ice Cream Cottage:
I can’t believe how much this place has change, does John still own it? I was trying to order a large birthday cake for next day pick up and couldn’t do it on-line, so I called and told them what I was looking for wasn’t there. There response was we can’t take cake orders over the phone how ridiculous. They just lost all the birthday cake business I have been giving them over the past twenty something years. What a s... View all feedback.
this is the only ice that eats our family, not a big brand ice cream for us. never had a bad ex...
astonishingly go to the ice place. ice is always delicious, ice cream are the best. I've been t...
Nostalgic and delicious. The only downside is it's small and you feel crowded with just 6 peopl...
For an ice cream shop it rocks. Service: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $1–10 Food...
Tons of flavor choices and unique ones toppings.Sell Ice cream cakes candy. The waffle bowls ar...
very nice place to create memories of an excellent ice cream. it is worth visiting and when you...
Long live Ice Cream Cottage! Best ice cream, best people, best memories! Also some popping rain...
My small Sunday was a joke...the size of a quarter whipped cream topping and maybe a tea spoon...