Star Island Yacht Club - MONTAUK

Most of the visitors of the Star Island Yacht Club were very satisfied with the service, the average rating is 3.7.

What Steven Lewandowski likes about Star Island Yacht Club:
Like many years, we dropped off 5lbs of fluke/seabass fillets for the takeout “you hook’em we cook’em” deal..they did a fantastic job (Blackened, General Tao’s and Tempura), delicious and doesn’t come any fresher then that!! Staff were very accommodating, food trays were well presented..added rice and we had more than enough for our group of 5 with leftovers..hence why we keep going back to them!! Food: 5 View all feedback.

What Nancy S doesn't like about Star Island Yacht Club:
Just left the yacht club....well actually got chased out by Alex the dock manager. My wife and I were enjoying amazing cocktails at the bar. Def try the dirty banana! The approach Alex used to have us move our boat to a slip was totally unnecessary and left a horrible taste in our mouths. We wanted to go into the store to buy multiple items but after the manager Alex was done talking to us. We just left. And we won't... View all feedback.