Full menu with prices & pictures
Jimmy O's 5658 N West Shafer Dr, Monticello, I...
(+1)2192538433
(+1)2192158303
Reserve a table now for Jimmy O's
A complete menu of Jimmy O's from Monticello covering all 37 courses and drinks can be found here on the menu. For seasonal or weekly deals, please get in touch via phone or use the contact details provided on the website.
What User likes about Jimmy O's:
We were eager to share our thoughts about this place: it's hands down the best pizza in Indiana! My family hails from Chicago, so we're always on the lookout for good pizza spots in Indianapolis. This place is conveniently located by the seashore and is definitely worth a visit! P.S. Don't miss out on the fried mushrooms as a delicious appetizer! View all feedback.
What Cynthia B doesn't like about Jimmy O's:
We always get our pizza from Jimmy O’s, and it's consistently delicious. For the past couple of years, my roommate has been raving about their Monday night classic hamburger special. So, we decided to give it a try, especially since a burger and fries for $5.00 sounded like a fantastic deal. I placed the order over the phone, and they confirmed the Monday special. However, when the total came to $29.70, I was shocked... View all feedback.
The food was good but not one staff was wearing a mask, not even our waitress,not the person wh...
Have had many good experiences at Jimmy O 's but last evening was a disaster. A group of us wen...
I was here three times a week, I spent in Monticello. Had fish and chips last Friday, they were...
Vanessa was an AWESOME server! She was open and honest about what was good and what wasn’t so g...
We visited the restaurant on Tuesday, September 22, and unfortunately, the food was very disapp...
The sandwiches are excellent, the pizza is fantastic, and the prime rib on Fridays is a great d...