Beer Church Brewing Co. - New Buffalo

The average evaluation of 3.9 shows that Beer Church Brewing Co. so far has satisfied the most of its customers.

What Taylor D likes about Beer Church Brewing Co.:
The only reason I go is for the pizza. It’s the BEST pizza around!!!! They have some friendly staff too! It’s hard to find servers that aren’t irritated by parties with children, so I’m very glad we got Haley as our server!! She was very sweet, made sure our food came out quickly and correctly, and made sure we never ran out of drinks. She was amazing!!!! Probably one of the best servers I’ve had in a long time. View all feedback.

What Carson Young doesn't like about Beer Church Brewing Co.:
Was seated quickly, atmosphere was nice. Prices were fair for what was presumably going to be an authentic fresh pizza. Outer crust was great along with the cheese but towards the center seemed to be undercooked and the amount of pepperoni didn’t match the $3 up charge. Waitress was friendly but didn’t seem overly interested in assisting. Not sure if it’s a fluke but was visiting from out of town and had high expecta... View all feedback.