Full menu with prices & pictures
Papa Johns Pizza 1315 4th St NW, 44663, New Philadelp...
+13303642900
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Papa Johns Pizza
A comprehensive menu of Papa Johns Pizza from New Philadelphia covering all 7 menus and drinks can be found here on the menu. For seasonal or weekly deals, please get in touch via phone or use the contact details provided on the website.
What User likes about Papa Johns Pizza:
I have ordered the same pizza 10+ times from here, never have I got one that I was disappointed in. I would highly recommend it if you like the garden pizzas, and the garlic sauce as the sauce base with the parmesan crust is a must. Made a Papa John's account just because of this reason. A+ experience so far. View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Papa Johns Pizza:
I ordered a New York style pizza using the Papa John's app for pick-up. When I arrived at the pick-up point, no one attended to me for over 10 minutes. I drove around the building to see if anyone was inside and eventually saw someone. I returned to the pick-up window and waited again. I ended up calling the restaurant to see if someone was coming with my order. A staff member finally arrived and took my order, but b... View all feedback.
We are on the fence with this ordering experience. The Papadias we got,Phila cheese Italian,wer...
I havent ordered from papa johns for a while....I was disappointed because I paid for 2 extra g...
The two pizzas we ordered were prepared exactly as requested. We opted for carryout service and...
This restaurant has the worst customer service I have ever experienced! I called at 8:15 to pla...