Full menu with prices & pictures
Barstow House 35 W River RdNY 13812, NICHOLS, Unit...
+16076997474
Reserve a table now for Barstow House
Here you can find the menu of Barstow House in NICHOLS. At the moment, there are 8 meals and drinks on the card. You can inquire about seasonal or weekly deals via phone.
A once-beloved spot that fell short on a return visit, with cold food and mediocre flavors. On the flip side, a fantastic small-town gem with impeccable service and delicious food that's worth a drive. Another review praised the restaurant's atmosphere, service, and Italian dishes, especially the meatballs. For a special occasion, another couple enjoyed excellent food and service, declaring the spot a hidden gem. A different reviewer appreciated the charming setting, excellent food, and diverse menu, but noted some issues with service. Overall, the restaurant offers a mix of experiences, making it a worthwhile choice for those seeking a cozy, authentic Italian meal.
What Joe H likes about Barstow House:
Probably one of the best places I've ever been in all my travels! What a wonderful small hometown place where the service hospitality were on point the food was spot on..... oh so good! I would drive the hour 45 minutes back to eat here again! View all feedback.
What Jody Mayo doesn't like about Barstow House:
Haven?t been here in years. Moved to SC. Back in town. Though it would be a nice place to take my girl who has never been here. It used to be a once a month or more dining pleasure. Not sure if it was just an off night but I was embarrassed. Food was cold, flavors were mediocre at best. Not at all what I remembered. Two stars as the waitress took good care of us. View all feedback.
The food is scrumptious and consistently served hot and fresh. The service is top-notch, and th...
The portions were a bit small for the price, and there weren't many gluten-free choices availab...