Osprey Bar Lounge - Shelter Island Heights

#19 - Pizza - Dering Harbor, Bar, American
11 Stearns Point Road Ste 2NY 11965, Shelter Island Heights, United States
Dishes: 76

Osprey Bar Lounge

4.4 / 5 of 47 Reviews
Phone
+16317495659
Address
11 Stearns Point Road Ste 2NY 11965, Shelter Island Heights, United States

Amenities

Amex
Discover
Mastercard
Visa Card
Corkage Fee
Counter Seating
Happy Hour
Non-smoking
Private Room
Wheelchair Access
Beer
Cafe
Cocktails
Wine
Menu
Reservation
Cocktails
Romantic
Great For Outdoor Dining
Porch
Innovative

Reserve now

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 of 47 Reviews

Caci received mixed reviews from patrons, with some praising the delicious food worth returning for. Others found the dishes bland despite the beautiful atmosphere and high prices. However, many highlighted the attentive service and pleasant dining experience. Despite some shortcomings, the restaurant was commended for offering high-end dining on Shelter Island. The outdoor dining option received positive feedback, with guests appreciating the low-key vibe and excellent pasta dishes. Overall, Caci was lauded as a quiet place with good service, a rarity on the East End, and diners expressed hope for its continued success.

Nice room, nice server, pricy. Eating on Island’s is always pricey

The steak for two was exceptional. Same for tuna tartare. The only complaint was that the floor...

The steak for two was outstanding, as was the tuna tartare. The only issue was that the restaur...

peters

We ordered the eggs Benedict which was fabulous!! The others ordered the scrambled eggs, more l...

floflo

Menu Items

More information

Related Restaurants

Fast & SimpleDownload Menulist App now