Full menu with prices & pictures
Old Guy's Italian 1961 McCrays Mill Road, Sumter, 2915...
+18037743043
A comprehensive menu of Old Guy's Italian from Sumter covering all 5 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu. For changing offers, please get in touch via phone or use the contact details provided on the website.
The average review for Old Guy's Italian is 4, which means that the visitors have a very high opinion of this restaurant.
What Dawn Hershey likes about Old Guy's Italian:
The food is fantastic!!! I would highly recommend the cheese steak. And the pepperoni roll. And the mushrooms. And the cheese sticks. Seriously, I would recommend everything on their menu!! I am from the north where Italian food is a way of life, and Andy and Sandy have brought that taste to Sumter, SC. I only wish it was closer to where I work and I would get lunch there every day. View all feedback.
What Big Sal's Pizza Review doesn't like about Old Guy's Italian:
Did a pizza review on this place crust was amazing but something was very very salty so I asked them if they wanted to remake the pie and after 10 min of waiting the owner was very very rude dont waste your time here rated 2.4 on crust alone View all feedback.
Did a pizza review on this place crust was amazing but something was very very salty so I asked...
The food is fantastic!!! I would highly recommend the cheese steak. And the pepperoni roll. And...