Full menu with prices & pictures
Gotham Bagels 112 E Mifflin St, Madison, Wisconsin...
+16084677642
+16082847145
Reserve a table now for Gotham Bagels
Here you can find the menu of Gotham Bagels in Madison. At the moment, there are 41 dishes and drinks on the card. You can inquire about changing offers via phone.
Gotham Bagels in Madison, WI is a popular American restaurant known for its delicious bagels with an average rating of 3.9 stars. Don't miss the opportunity to visit Gotham Bagels, open today from 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM. Make sure to call ahead and reserve your table at (608) 467-7642 to avoid waiting or missing out. If you're looking for similar options, consider checking out Sol's on the Square and Heritage Tavern. Leave a review if you've dined at Gotham Bagels before!.
What User likes about Gotham Bagels:
I love gotham and go every time I'm in Madison. The Tofu cream cheese is heavenly and the bagels are really good. make sure to ask for your roasted bagel vegan or not get it roasted because a few times I'm pretty sure I tasted butter on my bagel from the toasting it. the employees, in particular the owners, are often rude, not sure whether this is his personality or part of the “experience”. I don't like this mood pe... View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Gotham Bagels:
I used to be here. The Tofu cream cheese is really amazing! that is the best in this place. Unfortunately, everything else is sucked for me. starting with the rude service. the type that took my order was totally d*ck. his generally pussed-off-at-the-world vibe seemed to be shared by all employees. the music was bad. my bagel was stabbed. Maybe it was just a free day for her and you'll be better off. View all feedback.
Crazy busy nice staff food is ok way to high energy for me .. Great for college kids
It’s good, but it seems like they have execution problems. Why does it take 45 minutes to make...
these are the best bagels in the city, imagine my surprise though they also offer tofu spread i...
The bagels were super delicious and the tofu spread was surprisingly good. I'd never had a spre...
The bagels themselves are still good enough for the midwest, but the owner's New York service s...
Sandwiches are always great but since the pandemic and closing of the main dining room, other s...
I’ve never encountered such a diverse selection of bagel sandwich options. I ordered the Bright...
Without a doubt, the BEST bagels in Madison. I highly recommend their Piled High Pastrami bagel...