Full menu with prices & pictures
The Old Toad 277 Alexander St, 14607, Rochester,...
+15852322626
Reserve a table now for The Old Toad
A comprehensive menu of The Old Toad from Rochester covering all 19 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu. For seasonal or weekly deals, please get in touch via phone or use the contact details provided on the website.
This Rochester restaurant delivers a unique British pub experience with classic dishes like Shepherd's Pie and authentic fish and chips. While some customers may find the portions on the smaller side, the selection of beer, cheeses, and whiskies are well-loved. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, reminiscent of a local British pub. The staff are friendly and efficient, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Visitors often praise the warm and inclusive family-like ambiance, with one guest even comparing the fish and chips to a taste of home. Overall, this spot remains a favorite with many patrons, offering a delightful taste of England in upstate New York.
What User likes about The Old Toad:
This place is so unique and gives the real feeling of being transported to a local British pub. Many of the employees are British and even the pub furniture/bar... View all feedback.
What Jeff doesn't like about The Old Toad:
To my knowledge the only place in Rochester to get a scotch egg, and the only place that does actual shepherds pie with lamb (when made with beef it's cottage pie). The beer selection is fantastic, the food is delicious, and the staff are always friendly and awesome! The only thing I wish is that the portions were a bit more generous. View all feedback.
Food is okay (fish and chips are excellent however), beer selection is solid, but come for the...
that was a pleasant tasty bite that almost didn't happen. we came at 7:30 and there were so few...
The cutest, coziest little joint with the best British food.
To my knowledge the only place in Rochester to get a scotch egg, and the only place that does a...
Always great and interesting beers including a few pulled pints. Food is ENGLISH not Irish pub...
A satisfying and scrumptious meal. Very filling British cuisine with some German Oktiberfest mi...