Italian Restaurants in Carlisle
The best places in Carlisle to eat Italian. Our interactive map features all restaurants around Carlisle who offer this dish to eat out or take away.
Show 10+ restaurants on map
This is a list of all the eateries where you can order Italian or dine out.
Menu
Online table booking
Menu
Online table booking
City: Carlisle, 330 E Louther St, Carlisle, PA 17013, United States
The Menu of Pretzel Spot Cafe from Carlisle includes about 49 different dishes and drinks. On average, you pay for a dish / drink about $3.5.
4.7
Menu
Online table booking
4.7
Menu
Online table booking
City: Carlisle, 26 W High St, 17013, Carlisle, US, United States
"This hard to detect restaurant/escape room is a gem. Unfortunately, we had to start by parking in a lot and walking to the restaurant, as there was no parking available. Once we were inside though, we were delighted. We were greeted by live music and were taken upstairs to the upper seating. 2 of us had cider flights (6 each), and 3 of us had individual ciders. After trying every person's ciders, I could not believe how utterly impressed I was. I was not unhappy with a single one of them. They tasted amazing, it is no wonder they call themselves a cider place. The food was equally as good but a tad pricey. We started with an appetizer of the pretzel flight, where they give you 3 differently seasoned pretzels and 3 different sauces. (Best combo, Italian pretzel with garlic Parm sauce). I had the bbq chicken flatbread with cauliflower crust 3.50 extra). It was perfectly filling, gave a good amount of meat, sauce, and cheese. Everything was perfectly proportioned, and I left neither feeling hungry nor overly stuffed. My mom got the same but with the regular crust and was equally happy. My dad got the brisket flatbread and scarfed it down, but it was lacking in the meat. He suggests asking for a side of peppers to add to it for extra flavor. My fiance got the brisket sandwich and said there was a lot of meat, and the beer cheese was an amazing addition. Our friend comes here every week and said she has tried everything on the menu and has never been disappointed. We ended the meal with the cannoli dessert, which could've used a few more chocolate chips but was unique and tasty overall. I can't wait to come back here and maybe even try an escape room next time."
3.5
Menu
3.5
Menu
City: Carlisle, 872 Harrisburg Pike,PA 17013-1591, United States, Carlisle
"Great staff, great food. It's even a nice place to just sit and have a nice cold beer to be a sub shop. I've come in a couple of times back to back; and the regulars that come in on a daily basis are also very nice people... GREAT PLACE"
3.8
Menu
Online table booking
3.8
Menu
Online table booking
City: Carlisle, 40 Noble Blvd, 17013, Carlisle, US, United States
"Delicious pizza! Dough is great, and prices are very reasonable especially the deals. Atmosphere is good to eat in and time was fast enough to go as well!"
4.4
Menu
4.4
Menu
City: Carlisle, 598 W High St, 17013, Carlisle, US, United States
"Always a great choice! Great staff, excellent food."
4.3
Menu
4.3
Menu
City: Carlisle, 108 S Ledgerwood St, Carlisle I-47838-8207, United States
"Meat lovers deluxe minus pepperoni was fantastic fast service price Rite delivered quickly to truck stop at the edge of the city. Will be a retour customer from a doubt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
4.6
Menu
Online table booking
4.6
Menu
Online table booking
City: Carlisle, 60 School St, Carlisle I-50047-8782, United States
"Stopped here for our Valentine's Date Night.Seated right away on a Saturday evening around 5:15 pm. Our waitress was very friendly and helpful in deciding what options to choose for our meals. I also chose to have the Italian margarita since I love amaretto! It's sweeter than a normal margarita but was still delicious!We ordered the pickle fries. These were fantastic! Please try them when you're here.I ordered the Creamy Lemon Penne with chicken. The entree came with a side salad for which I ordered their creamy parmesan dressing. An Italian restraint staple! The dressing was amazing, garlic, and flavorful! The emtree also came with rolls and butter. The pasta sauce was not overly lemony, but enough of the flavor to give the dish a yummy kick.We also enjoyed a triple layer truffle cake for dessert. Boy am I stuffed, but this was the best Italian food I have had in a very long time from a restaurant!"
4.6
Menu
4.6
Menu
City: Carlisle, 330 S Hanover St, 17013, Carlisle, United States
"One of the best family owned restraunts in Carlisle ,delicious food great atmosphere .I absolutely love this place and recommend you stop in for a bite to eat."
Menu
Menu
City: Carlisle, 333 B Street, Carlisle, PA 17013, United States
The restaurant from Carlisle offers 10 different meals and drinks on the card at an average price of $6.1.
4
Menu
Online table booking
4
Menu
Online table booking
City: Carlisle, Cavalry Road, 17013, Carlisle, United States
"Best Italian in Carlisle!. Classic Mom- -Pop-Red-Sauce Italian. BYOB.<br/ <br/ Fair prices. Attentive and friendly staff. <br/ Consistently solid food.<br/ <br/ Carlisle restaurateurs please take some lessons from Marcello's"
{{ slotProps.result.rating }}
Featured
Menu
Online table booking
{{ slotProps.result.rating }}
Featured
Menu
Online table booking
City: {{ slotProps.result.city.name +
(slotProps.result.extended_address ? ', ' + slotProps.result.extended_address : '')
}}
{{ slotProps.result.custom_description.text | str_limit(150) }}
Italian
You can find Italian in 10+ Restaurants.
We help you find a restaurant in your area where it tastes best.
Price
The Average price for Italian is:
$8.5