Cosimo's - <a href

The average rating of 4.5 shows that the place is one of the top picks of all its customers.

What Cheflisa likes about Cosimo's:
Haven’t been here since I lived in Orange County and went to culinary school over 15 years ago. Are server Lisa was amazing and on point love a server who anticipates what customers need. I was craving Grilled chicken penne pasta and it tasted exactly like I remembered. Antipasto and bread was delicious. The decor looks great a warm and clean dining area and the bar area looks elegant View all feedback.

What Jessica P doesn't like about Cosimo's:
We had the worst experience last night and didn’t even make it passed the hostess stand. My parents are regulars at the Middletown location and refuse to go the Newburgh location and now I understand why. When we arrived there were 2 couples in the waiting area and we said we didn’t have a reservation and were told oh we don’t take reservations and it would be a 30 minute wait, understandable for a Friday night. Slow... View all feedback.