Images
ContributeNo images to show
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackThe average rating of this establishment is 4.5, which means that the Papa Joe's Italian Eatery is incredibly well seen by its customers.
What Jim D likes about Papa Joe's Italian Eatery:
Great authentic Italian fare. Courteous helpful wait staff (Betty). Prices were more than reasonable. Can't wait to return soon to try another dish!!! All 4 of us were impressed…thank you! View all feedback.
What Mark B doesn't like about Papa Joe's Italian Eatery:
This used to be one of my favorite restaurants, but ever since Covid, the menu has been much more limited. Could not even find beef on the menu unless you count meatballs. Very disappointed. I suspect the food is still very good, just not enough selections for me to go back, but I'll probably keep checking to see if they expand the menu again. Update: Stopped in for dinner on 12/30/22.Had the Fillet Florentine. Wish... View all feedback.
I ordered take out and they said it would be ready in one hour with a pick up time of 6:00 pm. At 6:30 I am still waiting for my order! Unacceptable!
BEST CATERING AND PRICING IN ROCHESTER! FOOD AND STAFF ARE INCREDIBLE!!! THANK YOU FIR MAKING OUR XMAS DINNER THIS YEAR!!! LOVE, THE PALOZZI/MOODY FAMILY
Full Menu
More information
Reservations can be made at this eatery over the phone, number: +15852477920.