Reviews
To date you have access to 398 ratings from 5 website(s). The median rating for Old Mill Inn is 4.7, signifying that this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests.
Reviews from various websites
MY God what can I say. The food was excellent. In Western NY the true test of a restaurant are the fish fries and their wings. My wife and I both ordered the be...
read moreIf your son or daughter are attending Alfred State or University, just take a little drive 10 minutes away to this cute place. Had a couple beers, watched the g...
read moreFirst time here. Took awhile to be served however, bartender was pleasant and made great drinks and recommendations on beers. Server was pleasant and we enjoyed...
read moreI had their cheese pizza yesterday and it was excellent. The crust had the perfect ratio of chewy to crispy. Seasoning was perfect. Cheese was gooey. AND it pas...
read moreWe hosted a party at our house with over 50 people attending. We called the Old Mill and spoke with Noah, who seemed excited for the opportunity. Communication...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more