Fishtale Ale House - Algoma

The average evaluation of 4 shows that the visitors have been very satisfied with the Fishtale Ale House so far, Furthermore, this restaurant is known as one of the best in Algoma, within the popular category Seafood.

What Noelle Newman likes about Fishtale Ale House:
2nd time here. Opened late yesterday due to being short staffed but was greeted with a smile. This was noted on facebook. Staff that was there was upfront about being short staffed, what food and beer options they did not have, which did not leave us guessing. Walleye sandwich was lightly battered and fried, soft bun, very good. Fresh walleye, still had a couple bones in it. Boneless wings not a fan, think more taste buds than anything, very saucy. Chicken with balsamic glaze/garlic sauce flatbed. Forgot the balsamic glaze but they fixed it by giving us some on the side, very good as well.

What Molly M doesn't like about Fishtale Ale House:
Pros: The bartender was nice and the sour selection was huge. Cons: Had the shark bite app was covered in a spicy mayo which was just gross. The walleye portion was fine, served with the skin on which I did not find appetizing, the mashed potatoes were bathing in a huge puddle of butter. Husbands burger was served cold. We were both so hungry we just ate what we could ad got the heck out of there. There was only 1 ba... View all feedback.