Reviews
What Steve likes about Bagel Boy:
As the busiest bagel store boasting Bay Ridge’s biggest bagels, they are basically continually baking. No fear of a staleness, but bulky bagels bring big crowds and soon after sunup on Saturday and Sunday, despite having a full staff hard at work, sometimes there is a lengthy waiting line. Their homemade style cakes are never labeled but always appear as if wrapped in plastic by an unsupervised five year old. Priced... View all feedback. What Yoselin Burgos doesn't like about Bagel Boy:
Bagel Boy is a staple, unfortunately the cashier is not. Going in today after being attended well I was rudely attended by one of the cashiers. Asked for 3 coffees all were burnt coffees. All 3 were not what I asked for. When it came to the bagel 2 done correctly the other a whole different bagel. Bread soggy, cheese incorrect as well as the toppings. I asked for Mayo and maybe he thought I was asking for a free bage... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The manager was so nicer then the ladyWho takes the orders and the bagels are so good
Good New York Brooklyn bagels,nice clean place to eat in...good looking salads also didn't get an chance to try the salads but will come back for it...
Bagel Boy is a staple, unfortunately the cashier is not. Going in today after being attended well I was rudely attended by one of the cashiers. Asked for 3 coff...
read moreGreat spot early morning for coffee and a bagel. You can be in and out in 2 minutes. Awesome bagel. Coffee was too sweet, wanted 1 sugar but got 2. Still coming...
read moreThese are the best bagels in Bay Ridge and I have tried them all.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreI like BB. They hv a delicious chocolate cream cheese muffin, their grilled chicken sandwich is enjoyable and filling, and good tea wth a nice strong cup to kee...
read moreSuperlative bagel purveyors worth a trip from points throughout Brooklyn. Plump, airy, pillowy bagels with a hint of sweetness and ideal combination of crusty e...
read moreBagel boy is the creme de la creme of bagels in bay ridge. They are always, always so busy and very packed all the time. It makes me feel good that they are bus...
read moreLawd hammercy this place is AMAZING! A must go if ur in Bay Ridge. Try the lox bagel with jalapeño cream cheese and thank me later honey! Food is amazing, servi...
read moreAs the busiest bagel store boasting Bay Ridge’s biggest bagels, they are basically continually baking. No fear of a staleness, but bulky bagels bring big crowds...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreAlways enough staff to handle the lines. You never need to wait more than 10 minutes for your order!
Delicious bagels, got 3 for free with the purchase of a dozen.
This is the best bagel in bay ridge and the staff are very friendly and the owner is very friendly and helpful and his son work the cashier his name is Paul jr...
read moreFinally got mini bagels....there brushetta is totally made wrong....there is no celery in brushetta....
The place to find your fresh salads and good sandwiches great place in town
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more