Palermo's Pizza Reviews (110)

Reviews

Overall Total Score

3.7 out of 5

Very good | 110 reviews

What User doesn't like about Palermo's Pizza:
I figured I would give this place a second try since my first time was not great. What a mistake! The worst calzone I have ever eaten! So salty it was like dumping a salt shaker in my mouth and by the way i love salt, the sauce tasted like it was spoiled and there was no ricotta cheese! I threw out most of it and what I did eat is now turning my stomach. It was absolutely awful. I would never order from this place ag... View all feedback. What User likes about Palermo's Pizza:
This is the best New York Pizza in Buckeye, AZ. Period. I cannot vouch for their other dishes. I just haven't had them. But their pizza is the best when fresh, hot, and same day. Or use the broiler, or air fryer to reheat. ENJOY! View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Good New York style pizza. Almost like being home. We've tried others and this is most authentic.

I figured I would give this place a second try since my first time was not great. What a mistake! The worst calzone I have ever eaten! So salty it was like dump...

We stopped in there on a trip through Buckeye. The food was good and plentiful, the beer was ice cold. My son absolutely loved the canoli. He wanted more. The s...

I went by the one bite, everybody knows the rules taste test...the Dave Portnoy rules on this pie, scale is 0-10, I give this pizza a 7.1... it 's a good pie, c...

This is the best New York Pizza in Buckeye, AZ. Period. I cannot vouch for their other dishes. I just haven't had them. But their pizza is the best when fresh,...

Last update : 11.02.2023

Victoria

26.06.2024 - 12:40

I figured I would give this place a second try since my first time was not great. What a mistake! The worst calzone I have ever eaten! So salty it was like dump...

Nick

26.06.2024 - 12:40

We stopped in there on a trip through Buckeye. The food was good and plentiful, the beer was ice cold. My son absolutely loved the canoli. He wanted more. The s...

Rob

26.06.2024 - 12:40

Nothing has changed still less than satisfying service. Staff makes comments about your order, the overall pricing has increased, value has dropped walked in as...

Last update : 26.06.2024

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Buckeye

8-bit Aleworks

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Avondale (near Buckeye), 1050 N Fairway Dr Building F Suite 101, 85323, Avondale, US, United States

"The only bad thing about this brewery is that it’s not smack in the middle of a community where people can walk there every night.Novel and delicious..."

#Casual

Details

Casual Brewery Chocolate Drinks Pub

Bosa Donuts

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Avondale (near Buckeye), 1713 N Dysart Rd, 85392, Avondale, US, United States

"Everything tasted great, and even added a few donuts!!"

##7 Cafés in Avondale

Details

#7 Cafés in Avondale Donut Shops

Robeks Fresh Juices Smoothies

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Goodyear (near Buckeye), 15525 W Roosevelt St #112, 85338, Goodyear, US, United States

"I love this place! Everything is ALWAYS fresh and perfect!"

#Delivery Services

Details

Delivery Services Juice Catering

Culver's

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Buckeye, 1540 N Verrado Way, Buckeye, United States

"This is not fast food?it?s good food fast. Stopped in on a road trip and was pleasantly surprised with the quality. We did the fish (cod) sandwich whi..."

#American

Details

American North American