Matthew's On Main St Reviews (605)

Reviews

Menulist has collected all the reviews for Matthew's On Main St from different websites to give you a unbiased impression. At present, there are 605 reviews from 6 website(s) available to you. The average rating for Matthew's On Main St is 4 which means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help our visitors with your review for this restaurant!.

Overall Total Score

4 out of 5

Impressive | 605 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Matthew's On Main St from all websites.

lisa-543

18.07.2023 - 09:35

Service was excellent. The food was excellent!

maureen-79

18.07.2023 - 09:35

Good American dining. Such a wide variety of food and always so fresh. It is one of my favorite restaurants in Sullivan county.

lexie-11

18.07.2023 - 09:35

Amazing food! The service cares so much! They were constantly making sure we were happy and let us know all our options! Which there were lots of! You can sit a...

rob-217

18.07.2023 - 09:35

Great place.. friendly host, owner and everyone in the place was very accommodating. Sat on the deck on a beautiful sunny summer afternoon. The service was grea...

christopher-146

18.07.2023 - 09:35

Staff was great and food was awesome. We had the special smoked trout blt and chinease dumpling soup, it was amazing. Wish we had ordered a larger order, so go...

Last update : 18.07.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Callicoon

Hennings Local

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Cochecton Center (near Callicoon), 6 Old County Rd, Cochecton Center I-12726, United States

"I just heard from this restaurant a few weeks ago on facebook, and I wait to try it. I thought everything was excellent. beautiful waiter, beautiful ambiente, generous portions, good drinks, everything was very tasty and beautifully plated. when they stop and realize where the place is. in the middle of cochecton. I would even add a few stars. the selection of fine restaurants in this area are slim, and this is a jewel. I'm glad to go back soon!"

##6 Fast Food in Cochecton...

Details

#6 Fast Food in Cochecton Center

Benji And Jake's

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: White Lake (near Callicoon), 5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, White Lake I-12749-7721, United States

"Pizza was excellent. Service was wonderful. Recommend the Gelato for dessert. $8/cup but so very yummy."

##2 Pizza in White Lake

Details

#2 Pizza in White Lake American

Callicoon Caffè

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Callicoon, 23 A Dorrer Dr, 12723, Callicoon, United States

"Great vibes and good views. Diner food is very average, don't expect the food to be fancy or anything like that."

##7 Cafés in Callicoon

Details

#7 Cafés in Callicoon Canadian

Local Table Tap (the)

Table booking

City: Kauneonga Lake (near Callicoon), 3 Horseshoe Lake Rd, 12749, Kauneonga Lake, United States

"Located on the lake, this place is perfect to sit and enjoy some leaf action. I had the cheeseburger, but it was way to salty.(I'll blame the blue cheese, which was my own choice). The French onion soup was just right on a cool day."

##7 Cafés in Kauneonga Lak...

Details

#7 Cafés in Kauneonga Lake American

Peppinos

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Callicoon, 31 Lower Main St, Callicoon, United States

"Really good mushroom pizza! the medium size is actually very large. service was fast and efficient. and a shout out to the guys who were making the pizza the day i ordered it was an extremely hot day, and to be stuck inside near a hot oven must have sucked (sorry, guys, for being oblivious when i decided to give in to my pizza craving)."

##7 Pizza in Callicoon

Details

#7 Pizza in Callicoon Italian

Callicoon Brewing Company

Table booking

City: Callicoon, 15 Upper Main St, 12723, Callicoon, United States

"Great food. Loved the fish and chips"

#American

Details

American North American Breweries

Catskill Distilling Company The Dancing Cat Saloon

4.1

Table booking

4.1

Table booking

City: Bethel (near Callicoon), 2037 NY-17B, Bethel, USA, 12720, United States

"It was very interesting to see how they make vodka and look at the beautiful building and look at the beautiful place the service was excellent the music was great and the hospitality was wonderful"

#American

Details

American Wine Fish Meat Drinks

White Owl

4.2

Table booking

4.2

Table booking

City: Beach Lake (near Callicoon), 318 Welcome Lake Rd, 18405, Beach Lake, US, United States

Accepts Credit Cards, TV, Wine, Credit

#Casual

Details

Casual Steak American Wine Desserts

The Laundrette

4.5

City: NARROWSBURG (near Callicoon), 20 5th St, Narrowsburg, New York, USA, 12764, NARROWSBURG, United States

"I've been coming to the Laundrette for about 5 years. This is the first time dining in under the new ownership. The drinks and salad were delicious. The host was very friendly and welcoming and the bartender was very attentive. The pizza was tasty butit's changed. The crust is not the same. It didn't have that amazing fluffy thin crust pizza quality. It was a bit dense andalmost felt like it was made with whole wheat flour? It's a beautiful spot... I just wish they'd fix the crust situation."

##5 Pizza in NARROWSBURG

Details

#5 Pizza in NARROWSBURG American

Sorella

4.1

Table booking

4.1

Table booking

City: White Lake (near Callicoon), 3562 State Rte 55, White Lake, USA, United States

"The personal was very rude, had no idea what the customers were. I have not neglected anyone except the phone, would rather eat crumbs than deal with a company that treats its customers in a negative disregard."

##8 Pizza in White Lake

Details

#8 Pizza in White Lake Italian Wine