Mayer's Tavern Reviews (258)

Currently you have 258 review from 4 website(s) available. The average rating for Mayer's Tavern is 4 which means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant.

Overall Total Score

4 out of 5

Impressive | 258 reviews

Reviews from various websites

nick-glogowski

22.12.2023 - 14:28

Bartenders and servers were great. Super helpful for out of towners. Gave us many recommendations outside of their establishment. Food was great. Burgers were s...

linda-rice-bailey

22.12.2023 - 14:28

It was a horrible experience. We waited over an hour for a 6 party. After we waited over an hour, we changed the res to 2, since the other 4 of our party couldn...

mike-nachtigall

22.12.2023 - 14:28

appetizers were great and also had the scaloops?

michael-kissinger-1

22.12.2023 - 14:28

Love it. My wife loved the burger,I loved the scallops. Nice atmosphere. Great service. Home made fries. Yum .

alexander-heck-2

22.12.2023 - 14:28

Awful food. Very limited menu. My burger was dry and even the lemonade was tart. Would not

Last update : 22.12.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near CAPE MAY

Spiaggetta Italian Seafood Trattoria

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: STONE HARBOR (near CAPE MAY), 9800 3rd Ave Stone Harbor, NJ 08247, 08247-1931, STONE HARBOR, United States

"Excellent...food and service. Tables for 2 a bit small but"

##7 Seafood in STONE HARBO...

Details

#7 Seafood in STONE HARBOR

Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

4.7

Table booking

4.7

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 516 Carpenter Ln,NJ 08204-2302, United States, CAPE MAY

"Super cute store super friendly staff beat peanut butter EVER!"

##24 Cafés in CAPE MAY

Details

#24 Cafés in CAPE MAY American

Roman`s Pizza House

4.3

City: CAPE MAY, 3718 Bayshore Rd, 08204, CAPE MAY, United States

"My new favorite pizza place!"

##8 Pizza in CAPE MAY

Details

#8 Pizza in CAPE MAY

The Blue Rose Inn

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 653 Washington St, Cape May I-08204-2324, United States, CAPE MAY

"Delicious food and friendly staff would love to go back"

##18 Vegetarian in CAPE MA...

Details

#18 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY American

Viggiano's on Sunset

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 109 Sunset BlvdNJ 08204, CAPE MAY, United States

"Very satisfied, food was great. Will definitely go back"

##1 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY

Details

#1 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY

Peter Shields Inn

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 1301 Beach Avenue Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-2700, CAPE MAY, United States

"Halibut was outstanding! Short rib was very good as well!"

#American

Details

American American Salad Wine Soup

Union Park Dining Room

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 727 Beach Ave, 08204, CAPE MAY, United States

"Got food poisoning from the tuna tartar."

##7 European in CAPE MAY

Details

#7 European in CAPE MAY European

Cold Spring Grange

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 735 Seashore Rd, Cape May I-08204-4636, United States, CAPE MAY

"Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4"

##5 Fast Food in CAPE MAY

Details

#5 Fast Food in CAPE MAY

H&h Seafood

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 956 Ocean Dr, Cape May I-08204-5400, United States, 08260, CAPE MAY

"Absolutely amazing seafood. abandoned atmosphere. is byob. eat their own pace. everything is fresh. their sides are homemade, and their cornbread is f..."

##1 Seafood in CAPE MAY

Details

#1 Seafood in CAPE MAY Gluten Free

The Merion Inn

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 106 Decatur St, Cape May I-08204-1415, United States, CAPE MAY

"All the way. The early bird special cannot be beaten. I had filled the grilled Portobello mushroom w/quinoa, with asparagus, potatoes and beautified b..."

##43 Vegetarian in CAPE MA...

Details

#43 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY Seafood