Peter Shields Inn Reviews (14890)

A restaurant without a rating is almost like a beer garden without a guest. Menulist has collected all reviews for Peter Shields Inn so you can get an impression based on the opinions of other customers. So far, there are 14890 reviews found on 5 pages. The average rating for Peter Shields Inn is 4.6, which means this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests. Help our visitors with your review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4.6 out of 5

Outstanding | 14890 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Peter Shields Inn from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (4.6 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in CAPE MAY.

adamd

30.03.2024 - 22:50

Always a great experience, and look forward to coming back. PSI is consistently good in food and execution.

celia-nieves

30.03.2024 - 22:50

Love the staff and atmosphere, would love to see a better variety on the menu ; especially main course, miss the tuna tartare, scallops, filet...also miss the p...

rdiioia

30.03.2024 - 22:50

We had a wonderful meal and excellent service. The atmosphere was delightful!

waltv

30.03.2024 - 22:50

Had another great dinner. Background piano music was excellent but noise level in room was a bit too loud.

hugh

30.03.2024 - 22:50

The food preparation, which is usually very good, was below average for a first class restaurant, we are sorry to say. Very disappointing for a $140 meal for tw...

Last update : 30.03.2024

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near CAPE MAY

Spiaggetta Italian Seafood Trattoria

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: STONE HARBOR (near CAPE MAY), 9800 3rd Ave Stone Harbor, NJ 08247, 08247-1931, STONE HARBOR, United States

"We appreciated the opportunity for alfresco dining on a beautiful night. The portions were generous and the food was well prepared. This was our first time dining here but we’ll definitely return."

##1 Seafood in STONE HARBO...

Details

#1 Seafood in STONE HARBOR

The Merion Inn

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 106 Decatur St, Cape May I-08204-1415, United States, CAPE MAY

"As always, fabulous!! The filled lobster... to die!! French onion soup, oysters, great!! The atmosphere is always fantastic, the piano, wonderful and Kathy our server, absolutely WONDERFUL!!"

##43 Vegetarian in CAPE MA...

Details

#43 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY Seafood

Roman`s Pizza House

4.3

City: CAPE MAY, 3718 Bayshore Rd, 08204, CAPE MAY, United States

"Reading your shirts legalize marinara. Eating is also good. Loud music playing outside there is an old skool party feeling."

##8 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY

Details

#8 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY

Panico's Bistro

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 422 Broadway, CAPE MAY, United States

Wheelchair Access, Wheelchair Accessible, Parking, BYO Liquor

##22 Cafés in CAPE MAY

Details

#22 Cafés in CAPE MAY Vegetarian

Oyster Bay Restaurant Bar

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 615 Lafayette St, Cape May I-08204-1518, United States, CAPE MAY

"Parking: They have their own lot, but it can get crowded. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Parking options: Free parking lot"

##24 Vegetarian in CAPE MA...

Details

#24 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY

Cold Spring Grange

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 735 Seashore Rd, Cape May I-08204-4636, United States, CAPE MAY

"I don’t think they are doing any indoor seating just yet so I thought we might sit on the porch where there are several tables. We got there shortly after opening and we noticed a brewery right next door. The hostess encouraged us to go over there and was kind enough to offer to bring our food to us as it’s only a few feet away. We ended up enjoying some drinks while we waited for our food and as promised it was brought over to us. Everything we ordered was really good but the brussel sprouts were AMAZING. I highly recommend a trip here!"

##5 Fast Food in CAPE MAY

Details

#5 Fast Food in CAPE MAY

The Blue Rose Inn

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 653 Washington St, Cape May I-08204-2324, United States, CAPE MAY

"Hands down the best Restaurant in Cape May. My wife and I have sat down multiple times at just about every restaraunt in Cape May, from the Ugly Mug to Peter Shields. Our top picks: The Ebbitt Room, The Washington Inn, and Union Square (for their seafood), but The Blue Rose climbs well above the rest. The quality and detail to each entree is spectacular. If you're a foodie and attempting to utilize Yelp to find that hidden gem in Cape May, the Blue Rose is it. I would also like to mention the fine decor, which I don't often comment on, but at the Blue Rose it's worth noting. Very classy and very deserving of every dollar spent."

##13 Vegetarian in CAPE MA...

Details

#13 Vegetarian in CAPE MAY Pizza

Merion Inn

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 106 Decatur StreetNJ 08204, CAPE MAY, United States

"Dinner was delicious. On arrival the noise level was too loud. It was very difficult to get a drink at the bar because of the crowd."

##20 Seafood in CAPE MAY

Details

#20 Seafood in CAPE MAY American

Washington Inn

4.7

Online table booking

4.7

Online table booking

City: CAPE MAY, 801 Washington Street Cape May, NJ 08204, 08204-1644, CAPE MAY, United States

"I like the atmosphere. Very noise yon a Saturday night. Food portions were small. I had the cod. It was very tasty but small. After dinner we sat outside bye the fire pit. Very cozy and relaxing."

##2 European in CAPE MAY

Details

#2 European in CAPE MAY European