Old Captiva House - Feedback

Had to wait 1/2 hours, even though we had a reservation. we often go here and it's always pretty good. think they were overwhelmed

Eating was amazing and the service was spectacular. highly recommended!

Freshly created since hurricane ian, little to no damage, clean, well ordered, bright and unbreakable. pleasant waiting staff, very reasonable prices. eating wa...

We had dinner in the old captiva house am silvester. the menu selection was very nice. we were warmly welcomed by the hostess; our server, tony, was very good a...

We had breakfast and dinner here. The food was delicious and the service was excellent which is amazing in light of hurricane Ian just 3 months ago.

Had a work event at the Marriott Sanibel resort and I wanted to see the island, it had been since 2019. Found this restaurant based on a Yelp GF search. Made a...

We had a nice butt pricey dinner at old Captiva house. I had a good Caesar salad with lots of Areman cheese, and the house garden salad was very good. We had gr...

The food was very good as was the service. Just be sure to ask how much the special is. We got our bill and our jaws dropped!

Love love love. The Cioppino is my go to here, and we go on multiple nights when we stay at Tween. Service is attentive and welcoming. We've also eaten breakfas...

Samantha, the hostess doesn't have the personality to be greeting people at a such nice high end restaurant Get rid of Samantha and everything will be great

Celebrated our 40th anniversary and everything was terrific. Food, atmosphere and all staff made it a great dining experience. Will be returning soon…

Food and drinks were great management did nothing to assist with the heat issue. They instead replied to the sweltering conditions as “well it’s hot out” when i...

Our server, Marco, was fantastic. He made excellent recommendations and was very attentive, but not overbearing.

We would have given this restaurant a much higher rating if it were not for the Twin Lobster Tails that cost $62. They were overcooked, dry and tasteless. The b...

Great as usual. Came for our anniversary and had a fantastic dinner. Lobster risotto was perfect. I had the fish special which was very good and my wife has the...

What a treat. We came in town for a short spontaneous vacation and found this phenomenal restaurant. Getting there at sunset by itself was already worth it. The...

We had an excellent meal in this lovely historic space with a view of the water. The lobster and crab crusted scallops on coconut rice was amazing. The Branzino...

Very nice, relaxing environment with big open windows. We were there on a rainy day and it was very calming seeing the rain outside the window. The service was...

I had the Fisherman’s stew which was the best seafood dish of my life. The broth was genuinely addictive. Wine was great too. Incredibly beautiful setting, espe...

Fantastic meal, all four entrees. Highly recommend the Cioppino! Nice ambiance, good service and not too loud.