Reviews
A establishment without a rating is almost like a beer garden without a guest. Menulist has collected all reviews for Godfathers Pizza Cayuga so you can get a picture based on the opinions of other customers. So far, there are 336 opinions found on 3 pages. The average rating for Godfathers Pizza Cayuga is 3.6, which means the vast majority of its guests was satisfied with its service. Help our visitors with your review through our rating system.
Reviews from various websites
All reviews for Godfathers Pizza Cayuga from all websites.
Tripadvisor
Google
INT Restaurants
Good Rated Restaurants near Cayuga
4.7
Menu
Table booking
4.7
Menu
Table booking
City: Simcoe (near Cayuga), 126 Robinson St, N3Y 1W9, Simcoe, Canada
"Love this place. Their cookies are my favorite Also the color changing purple tea is super fun! Inside is very inviting and I love the cozy aesthetic. Staff is super friendly as well. Glad to finally have a new coffee shop in town."
4.4
Menu
Table booking
4.4
Menu
Table booking
City: Simcoe (near Cayuga), 358 Queensway West, Simcoe I-N3Y 2N2, Canada
"Great customer service and amazing talent for customizing my ice cream cake!"
4.4
Menu
Table booking
4.4
Menu
Table booking
City: JARVIS (near Cayuga), 2091 Main St N, Jarvis, Ontario N0A 1J0, Canada, N0A1J0, JARVIS
"Went here for lunch after an outing with my family, the food we got was good... Although it wasn't the right food we ordered. Asked the staff to correct it and they reluctantly took it back, only to still get the order wrong. Overall a good meal with unpleasant staff. Would probably still visit again."
4.5
Menu
Table booking
4.5
Menu
Table booking
City: Port Dover (near Cayuga), 243 Main St | Main and Market, Port Dover, Ontario N0A 1N0, Canada, N0A1N0
"Amazing food, amazing service & beautiful atmosphere. Love the daily specials as well as the regular menu."
4.4
Menu
Table booking
4.4
Menu
Table booking
City: Selkirk (near Cayuga), 1 Main St W, Selkirk, Ontario N0A 1P0, Canada, N0A1P0
"We drove to Selkirk to walk the Wheeler's Trail in the provincial park. But with all the recent rains, the trail was too muddy. So we walked along Lakeshore to get in our morning steps. Then back to Selkirk for breakfast, we read a review last year about it and always enjoy breakfast out. Good server, good coffee, good home cooked food. My husband always orders his eggs over medium, and the yolks always come out too runny or too hard. Not this time they were just right! Really good bacon too, with a smoky aftertaste. The review also mentioned that they had great carrot cake, so we ordered two pieces to take home. Carrot cake is our favourite dessert, we order it whenever we see it on menus, so feel we can judge the offerings pretty well. I don't know what the reviewer was eating, but this was truly the worst carrot cake we have ever had. The texture was weird, very granular, almost as if made with cornmeal. It wasn't listed as gluten free, which can have a weird mouth feel. Also missing were the lovely combo of spices that you usually find in carrot cake. It was very dry. However, the cream cheese frosting was excellent. SO if we lived closer to Selkirk, this would definitely be on our list of regular breakfast spots. The carrot cake not so much!"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
4.6
Menu
Table booking
City: Port Dover (near Cayuga), 401 Main St, Port Dover, Ontario N0A 1N0, Canada, N0A1N0
"This is a cute little cafe style restaurant on the main strip. Lovely patio atmosphere, delicious food. I highly recommend the coconut cauliflower soup! Something for everyone! I am vegan and had no trouble finding something great! And my meat-eating companions also enjoyed their meal just as much! Great service, decent prices! I would definitely go back!"
4.4
Menu
Table booking
4.4
Menu
Table booking
City: Port Dover (near Cayuga), 168 New Lakeshore Road, Port Dover, Ontario N0A 1N3, Canada, N0A1N3
"We had our 48th anniversary dinner here. the atmosphere, server and eating were absolutely fabulous! highly recommended!"
4.2
Menu
Table booking
4.2
Menu
Table booking
City: Port Dover (near Cayuga), 211 Main St, Port Dover, Ontario N0A 1N0, Canada, N0A1N0
"A really good dinner here and our server, michelle, was very helpful in taking a pizza would be sufficient for the two ladies. the pizza was made with a flower cabbage crust that was surprisingly good, not almost as heavy as pizza with regular...pizza pot. the toppings were also very good. the men thoroughly enjoyed the apfelbrie grilled cheese sandwiches with chicken breast, cut apples, pan fried wobbles, coy jam, garlic aoli, brie and cheddar cheese on sourdough brot, along with a very good side caesar salate and I am no fan of cumshots. these were certainly not easy and they were delicious! we will return the next time in port dover."
4.5
Menu
4.5
Menu
City: Port Dover (near Cayuga), 511 Main St Unit 3, N0A 1N0, Port Dover, Canada
"Solid lunch spot, they have a box with a few things in it that can easy feed 3 of us for like 20-25$"
4.4
Menu
4.4
Menu
City: Simcoe (near Cayuga), 2541 Hwy 24 RR 4 Stn Main, Simcoe I-N3Y 4K3, Canada
"First time at the shop and I will make a point of coming back nothing any better than home cooked meal food is awesome and the people that work there awesome they're all chitter-chatter e lol highly recommended"