Sebastian's from Cincinnati Menu

Sebastian's, a long-standing Cincinnati staple known for its delicious gyro sandwiches, has recently undergone some changes under new ownership. While some loyal customers have been disappointed with the new menu items such as greasy gyro meat and subpar grape leaves, others continue to praise the consistency of the food over the years. Despite mixed reviews regarding the quality and authenticity of the Greek dishes, Sebastian's remains a nostalgic favorite for many, offering a no-frills dining experience in a familiar neighborhood setting. Whether you're a longtime regular or a newcomer looking for authentic Greek cuisine, Sebastian's still holds its place as a go-to spot for a tasty gyro in Cincinnati.

Last update: 10.10.2024

Images

Contribute

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

Contribute Feedback

What Joey likes about Sebastian's:
A must if visiting Cincinnati! I've had my fare share of gyros but the Gyro that they serve( usually served by a little Greek man named Alex) is phenomenal. You gotta get it with extra tiziki sauce! View all feedback.

What Jim Mercer doesn't like about Sebastian's:
The new owner has ruined Alex's world famous food. The new gyro meat is greasy and the sauce doesn't even come close and appears to be canned bought. The new grape leaves are disgusting. I spit them out. The atmosphere is new and looks clean but they have lost/disposed of the old world European eatery. What a shame.Food: 1/5 View all feedback.

LLOYD

21.07.2023 - 20:07

I've been to this long time staple more times than I can count over the years as I am born and raised as a Cincy Westsider. Sebastian's servers up a delicious,...

21.07.2023 - 20:07

My visit to Sebastian’s was completely unplanned. I call it an unexpectedly tasty adventure. After a morning of delivering presents for Angel Tree, my good fr...

Reyes

15.09.2023 - 06:44

I love the gyros! Took a long break after new owners took over, but that was my loss. The food is good if not better than before. The interior certainly looks a...

Adam

15.09.2023 - 06:44

Love this spot! Authentic and very charming! Food was absolutely fantastic.Food: 5/5

Tú

29.11.2017 - 10:19

I absolutely love Sebastian's!!! Watching the lamb being carved right in front of me is greatYou seriously couldn't get it any fresher.

Dereck

29.11.2017 - 10:19

The best gyro in town hands down! Thinly shaved, moist, simply prepared, excellent flavorThe tzatziki is thin and actually a sauce vs.

Full Menu

Download Menu

More information

QR-code link to the menu

This restaurant offers

Suggested nearby restaurants.

Mom 'n 'em Coffee Wine

4.9

Table booking

4.9

Table booking

City: Cincinnati, 3128 Colerain Ave, Cincinnati, United States

"I love this place! You have a lot of great drinks options, including beer, cocktails and even a lazy milkshake. Good food includes breakfast sandwiche..."

#American

Details

American North American