Reviews
What User doesn't like about The Colden Mill:
Menu items not as tasty as they used to be. Pre-pandemic was my favorite stuffed pepper in WNY. Now they wrap it in a flour tortilla and deep fry it. Less pepper, less stuffing. My wife could barely eat the meatloaf because of the texture. Seems the meat was pureed and had the consistency of mashed potatoes. The service and ambience remain great. Prices have gone up, but that is fairly universal. $9 for a pint of bee... View all feedback. What User likes about The Colden Mill:
The only complaint we had was that we were barely able to taste the alcohol in our drinks, and we are not heavy drinkers. Given the cost of these beverages, you expect to at least taste the alcohol. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
It was outstanding! Food was excellent! Nice quiet and cozy atmosphere. Went on St Patrick's Day and was still not busy. We probably didn't even need reservatio...
read moreIt was a lovely evening with the snow falling it was beautiful, looking out the windows and the fire in the stove was so warm and cozy. The food was very good a...
read moreAwesome aesthetic, food was delicious and large portions! Will definitely be coming back.
This is now our goto place for a nice quit dinner. The food is all made in the kitchen and it is great.
I really wanted to like this spot. Went for Saturday night dinner with my husband. For appetizers, he ordered the soup of the day (stuffed pepper) and loved it....
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreMy family and I (four people) made a reservation for 8pm to celebrate important milestones in our lives. When we arrived there was no other customers there, exc...
read moreOnion soup both ways, grilled Romaine- amazing! Mine and my husband's steaks were on point. Our waitress is always wonderful. We meet our friends for dinner her...
read moreI ordered the grilled Caesar salad, but it turned out to be quite cold and consisted of whole romaine lettuce leaves, not torn up at all. To my surprise, there...
read moreThe food was excellent, featuring some unique and delicious dishes. The onion soup is outstanding and could almost be a meal on its own. The fish fry was defini...
read moreThe ribeye and strip steak were fantastic, and the apple fritter dessert was absolutely incredible. It made for a wonderful anniversary dinner.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more