Reviews


By now you have 3145 evaluation from 9 website(s) available. The average rating for The Cottage is 4.1 which means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant.

Overall Total Score
4.1 out of 5
Impressive | 3145 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Menulist
3.2 ★ from 5 reviews
Brennan
10.04.2022 - 20:53

with the woman to lunch. she had an salate and I had the patty melt. both dishes were good, and the fried cauliflower app was fresh, hot and crispy.

Bettie
10.04.2022 - 20:53

the first time in years will probably wait another and not yet return. wait they personal helpful and friendly and deep roasted cheese curds we are delicious.

David
10.04.2022 - 20:53

what a great place! we didn't know it was an Irish bar and by chance it was the weekend before st. patricks tag. for us, we were.

Saul
28.11.2017 - 12:51

Thank you to the owner Paul to responding to our issues.

Marjolaine
28.11.2017 - 12:51

If you have a party of 5 but table sits 6 you don't get the table even if people come 45min later. **** poor. Who is running the show.

The Cottage restaurant has received a mix of reviews from customers. Some have been disappointed with the new management and service, experiencing issues with online orders and reservations. Others have mentioned the subpar quality of certain dishes, such as the stuffed Jalapenos and sweet potato fries. The ambiance of the outdoor patio was also noted to be lacking, with sticky tables and a less-than-ideal viewing experience for sports games. Despite these negative aspects, some patrons have praised the food quality and service, particularly highlighting the winter menu specials and the friendly server Crystal. Overall, it seems that The Cottage may have some areas for improvement, but there are also positive aspects that could make it worth a return visit.

Yelp
3.5 ★ from 143 reviews
Karolina
18.10.2024 - 06:44

The Cottage is a local fave. I love the atmosphere of the inside. Feels like you're in a pub overseas. It is important to understand that this is a no fuss kind...

read more
Eric
18.10.2024 - 06:44

The Cottage was exceptional! I had their prime rib sandwich on Texas toast with mozzarella, no horse radish sauce but a side of their creamy ranch, and they're...

read more
Joe
18.10.2024 - 06:44

Have been here several times. The fish fry is good and there are a lot of other choices. Food is good and the outdoor deck is always packed during the summer.

John
18.10.2024 - 06:44

I've been going here for years and always liked it. Today I went there for lunch and sat down at the bar. I was minding my own business and playing a game on my...

read more
Nelson
18.10.2024 - 06:44

My wife and I had dinner on Saturday, March 23 at The Cottage in Crystal Lake before a show at the Raue Center. It's a pub atmosphere. Very nice. They brought u...

read more
Opentable
4.4 ★ from 221 reviews
Skubedoo
28.10.2024 - 06:19

Excellent waitress. Cauliflower appetizer was tasty. Cottage pizza was very good but crust on veggie pizza was soggy. We'd like to return when it's warmer and s...

read more
SandieB
28.10.2024 - 06:19

Stopped here for dinner before going to the theater. It’s a great place for casual dining. I had the shrimp basket and my aunt had the cottage pie. Both were gr...

read more
NancyE
28.10.2024 - 06:19

We both had a cheeseburger and the spinach dip. The food was excellent!

Anita
28.10.2024 - 06:19

Got the fish fry. Overcooked, old grease. Third straight bad fish fry over multiple months. Won’t get it again. I am a neighbor, so the cottage is our “go to” p...

read more
KarenH
28.10.2024 - 06:19

Friendly service was quick and efficient, and the entrees were hot and delicious. We will be back soon.

Google
4.3 ★ from 1331 reviews
shane
04.02.2024 - 21:24

Always enjoy cold drinks and yummy food while at the Cottage, stopped in thus tine for a few **** Mary's and Oysters. Very tasty

The
04.02.2024 - 21:24

Parking is a bit tricky, be prepared to park a bit away. The food was great with a fantastic Irish pub menu. Service was friendly and accommodating!

Bryan
04.02.2024 - 21:24

Paul Leech, the owner is a local legend. He run the best restaurants and bars in town. Period.

Kimberlee
04.02.2024 - 21:24

Nice local place! I liked the food I tried, and the service was great!

Ally
04.02.2024 - 21:24

1st time here, surprise party. Very attentive staff and good food

Sirved
4.0 ★ from 687 reviews
Taylor
26.01.2024 - 17:44

The food was decent. The pizza crust was a little soggy and the prime rib was overcooked. The fried cheese balls were the best part. The bathroom smelled like u...

read more
annabanana
26.01.2024 - 17:44

We went to The Cottage to watch the Bears vs Green Bay game. We ordered the stuffed Jalapenos and they were horrible. We sent them back. The tables on the outsi...

read more
Gretchen
26.01.2024 - 17:44

Honestly, the new management and staff are an embarrassment. We made a reservation for 7 and sat at our table for 15 minutes with no service, no recognition and...

read more
Charlene
26.01.2024 - 17:44

It is a bar atmosphere, some TV'S available to watch sports. There are some great dishes, but most of the menu is average and average priced.

Robert
26.01.2024 - 17:44

The service was great, fries under cooked, and chicken sandwich was thinner than Wendy?s.

INT Restaurants
4.3 ★ from 1021 reviews
Restaurantji
3.8 ★ from 235 reviews
MenuWithPrice
4.4 ★ from 243 reviews
Gastroranking-US
3.8 ★ from 595 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Crystal Lake

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Pingree Grove (near Crystal Lake), 230 Reinking Rd, 60140, Pingree Grove, US, United States
"Mediocre ice cream. Unfriendly staff..."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 5011 Northwest Hwy Crystal Lake, IL 60014-7330, United States
"Weekends crowded and quite noisyBreakfast food is so so."
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 5005 Northwest Hwy, Crystal Lake I-60014-7324, United States
"Happy we stopped by because of small business Saturday and I am glad we did. Super cozy, fun and relaxing atmosphere. Everything looks so good and whe..."
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 75 E Woodstock St Crystal Lake, IL 60014-4364, United States
"Best pizza hands down in Chicago, at least for me."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 5690 Northwest Hwy, Crystal Lake, United States Of America
"We really like this place! One of our favorites for a local mommy daughter date. I love the fact that they are several roles with mango! We haven't tr..."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 90 N Williams St, Crystal Lake I-60014-4444, United States
"Love this place, the food and staff!"
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 110 North Main Street, Crystal Lake, 60014, United States Of America
"Great food . friendly service. Lots of seating also fresh salad."
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 6500 Northwest Hwy, 60014, Crystal Lake, US, United States
"Best ice cream and amazing mint shakes"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 1500 Carlemont Dr, Crystal Lake I-60014-1833, United States
"This place is always good. Great food, steller margs and even better service. Customers for life here!Food: 5/5"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Crystal Lake, 5899 Northwest Highway, Crystal Lake, 60014, United States Of America
"Great food, even better staff. I love the sauce selections."