Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Amy likes about Tony's New York Pizza:
Great pizza joint. Their pizzas are great, but their pizza knots leave a lot to be desired. They are basically garlic buttered rolls. Great homely restaurant and we love to come here after church. The bruschetta pizza has a weird crust and wasn’t as impressed by it. View all feedback.
What P Williams doesn't like about Tony's New York Pizza:
The food is just ok. My fiance liked the pizza but I thought it was under cooked. The garlic rolls seemed like they had been cooked, cooled down, and possibly re-heated. I didn't really care for them. My daughter got spaghetti with meat sauce. She thought it was spicy but she's 12. I had some and it was delicious. I really it a lot. The service was great and the store is clean. The parking is terrible. I hadn't been... View all feedback.
My wife grew up in upstate New York and has been searching all her life foe a 'New York Pizza ' like the ones she grew up with. Tony 's has come the closest and we will definitely be back. If you are concerned about crowds, this may not be your place. Still you can grab a slice and go, or order out. Even though they were busy, we were served in a timely manner and got our food pretty quick. And the place is well staffed with friendly wait staff and bus boys.
Formerly a resident of New York for over 45 years. Nobody makes pizza in Florida like they did in New York, but I must say, after living in Florida since 2005, Tony's New York pizza is the very best pizza I have had in Florida since I moved here. My only disappointment is that I live 45 minutes away. I guarantee you, whenever I am nearby, I will be eating pizza for dinner that night at Tony's. The prices are reasonable. There is plenty of parking across the street. You might wanna get there early, because there wasn't a table available by the time I was knee deep in pizza. Got ours with extra cheese and meat balls.
Our FIRST time ever experiencing Tony's it was beyond imaginable!! We will be back anytime we want some more pizza forever! We had the garlic knots pepperoni pizza! All was to DIE for! The service was phenomenal! We were there right at rush hour for dinner on a SATURDAY during COVID even THEN, the service was beyond belief!!!!! They deserve some kind of award!! I will forever go back to this establishment anyyyyyyytime I am craving some Italian! And I haven't tried anything else, other than the pizza garlic knots! But they have a loyal customer for the rest of my life!!! THANK YOU TONY!!!!! God bless
Love this place! The pizza is so good along with everything else! The staff is friendly and you can't beat the prices on food this good.
Nice place to eat. Owners usually there and talk to customers. Reasonably priced meals
Full Menu
Soups
Calzone
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
Toppings
More information
QR-code link to the menu
