Conestoga Steak House - Dothan

What Stephanie Wallen likes about Conestoga Steak House:
The best steak I’ve had in years, or possibly ever! I always order my steak tips well done, which can be risky, but these were amazingly tender, juicy and flavorful! The homemade rolls were delicious too. The only reason I did not give 5 stars, is the fact that they do not have real butter for those amazing rolls. That is doing a disservice to those rolls. I should also add that the atmosphere is lacking. It is old s... View all feedback.

What Madison Pike doesn't like about Conestoga Steak House:
Fries were good, shrimp skewers amazing. Pretty sure my hamburger was a frozen patty put in the skillet. Looked like something you would get at a school cafeteria. Filet mignon cooked right, but no flavor. I’ve had a lot better filets and this one was so disappointing. View all feedback.