Reviews
Currently, you have 263 appraisals from 1 website(s) on hand. The midpoint valuation for Mitchell's Fish Market - Edgewater is 4, this indicates guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Overall, the reviews for this restaurant are mixed. Some customers found the food to be underwhelming, with issues such as meals not being hot, high levels of salt, and bland flavors. Others had positive experiences with creative and delicious dishes. Service was another point of contention, with complaints about slow service, forgetful waitstaff, and inattentive waitresses. On the other hand, some patrons praised the friendly and accommodating staff. The view of the Manhattan skyline was consistently cited as a highlight, offering a spectacular backdrop for the dining experience. The atmosphere was deemed great for special occasions, date nights, and enjoying the view. While some reviewers noted the need for decor updates and issues with reservations, many customers were looking forward to returning for the warm weather months. Overall, the restaurant seems to have its strengths in scenic views and decent food, but inconsistency in service and food quality may affect the overall experience.
Reviews from various websites
the environment was wonderful with spectacular views of the hudson towards skyline. the food was well prepared and the service was on site. I would recommend mi...
read moreOur first experience was a good one after the museum hours on Friday evening. High quality menu, professional service and live music made for a nice date. Now M...
read moreThe food was okay but the service was terrible. The server didn't really know what to do. She didn't bring the water until I asked her three times. She even for...
read moreI got the goat cheese noodles that had goat cheese in the sauce and a whole ball of goat cheese on top. This is far too much goat cheese! Plus the taste was bla...
read moreThey never disappoint with service or food preparations and the view is spectacular always beautiful looking at the New York City skyline from the N.J. side. Ca...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more