Gills By The Bay Reviews (1262)

Reviews

Menulist has collected all the reviews for Gills By The Bay from different websites to give you a comprehensive impression. At present, there are 1262 reviews from 2 website(s) available to you. The average rating for Gills By The Bay is 4.4 which means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help our visitors with your review for this establishment!.

Overall Total Score

4.4 out of 5

Impressive | 1262 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Gills By The Bay from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (4.4 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Eureka.

This is one of my favorite places. I'm so glad they made it through the pandemic. Great food. Always great. I'm going to Gills for at least 20 years. Service is...

Nice little place on the bay. Hot fresh fish perfectly cooked! My husband enjoyed the shrimp sandwich and onion rings. Excellent, friendly service! They were cl...

Ordered shrimp cocktail, oyster shooter and 2 crab sandwiches (a hot cold). Everything was fantastic! I don't know what crab sandwich I enjoyed more, both of th...

Delicious!!! Best dining experience! Service had a warm welcoming and friendly feel to it. Attentive service, love the 50’s vibe! Will definitely be back next t...

I've been working in Arcata and been coming here before heading into town. The view is amazing and the staff is great as well. I've been getting different dishe...

Last update : 15.06.2023

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near Eureka

Cafe Nooner

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 2910 E St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States

"The menu sometimes changes, so there is always something new to discover. There are very few Mediterranean restaurants in Humboldt County, and this is a good place for breakfast or Med cuisine. Good options for Veg/Vegans."

##13 Fast Food in Eureka

Details

#13 Fast Food in Eureka

Humboldt Smokehouse

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 310 5th Street, Eureka, 95501, United States Of America

"This place is the goods!"

##31 Mexican in Eureka

Details

#31 Mexican in Eureka Bbq Sandwiches

Fresh Freeze Drive-in

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 3023 F St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States

"Probably one of the best burgers I've had here in Eureka, I order the Humboldt and it was delicious, juicy and big, double patties, melted cheese, all the necessary's for a great hamburger. I've made it a point to try hamburgers from different restaurants here in Eureka and Fresh Freeze has by far the best for the best price."

##26 Fast Food in Eureka

Details

#26 Fast Food in Eureka American

Murphy's Markets

4.6

Online table booking

4.6

Online table booking

City: Eureka, Eureka, United States Of America, 95503

Delivery, Reservations, Wifi, Wheelchair Accessible

##8 Sushi in Eureka

Details

#8 Sushi in Eureka

Ramones Bakery Cafe

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Eureka, Eureka, United States Of America, 95501

"Delicious food and drinks. They give you many options to curve every appetite. Cashiers and waiters were very attentive with solid suggestions. Management seemed to not understand mimosa’s that we ordered. Took away glasses and explained multiple times things we already knew. Would suggest they relax on the hands on and let employees handle the situations. Also the plates of food were not timed well causing us to wait for each other’s plates up to 15 minutes."

##5 Pizza in Eureka

Details

#5 Pizza in Eureka

Luis's Mexican

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 946 West Ave, Eureka I-95501-1266, United States

"Luis is always a wonderful meal. Dive in, terrace or drive through. Fresh chips and salsa. Much to choose from the menu. My favourite is Chili Verde about beans with flour tortillas. Absolutely delicious."

##13 Vegetarian in Eureka

Details

#13 Vegetarian in Eureka

Humboldt Bay Bistro

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 1436 2nd St, 95501, Eureka, United States

"The food was adequate. Took forever for someone to take our order. Called to do a to go before i came. Was on hold for 6 minutes. Made it to the restaurant before my order was taken. When we got there it took another 10 minutes to get the order. Asked for our french onion soup while we waited for our food. Have my pregnant wife a literal cup of broth with no bread and or cheese. We had to point that out. Good thing we got it ahead of time. That would have been messed up if we had gone home. When they get busy the service really goes down. Lots of mistakes. Also, I added an updated menu so people can see the correct prices. Side bote: if you order a soup with your meal such as french onion there is a $3 up charge, even though soup or salad comes with you meal. They do NOT tell you this. You find out when the bill comes."

##7 Sushi in Eureka

Details

#7 Sushi in Eureka

Philly Cheese Steak Shoppe

4.6

Online table booking

4.6

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 3050 Broadway Eureka, CA 95501, United States

"That's great! As close as you can come to an authentic Philly cheese steak."

#Sandwiches

Details

Sandwiches Delis Meat Cheese

Brick & Fire

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Eureka, Eureka, 1630 F St, 95501-2949, United States

Takeout, Delivery, Street Parking, Wheelchair Accessible

##4 Pizza in Eureka

Details

#4 Pizza in Eureka

The Sea Grill

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Eureka, 316 E St, 95501, Eureka, United States

"Had dinner reservations for Saturday night (Party of 2). We arrived early and sat in the bar for a drink before we went to the dining room... Food was very good: roasted Calamari star was excellent, salad cahowder next to and then 2 Entrees, Snapper saliva, all very good.... no room for dessert (although it was offered). The stars of the show and the reason for the 5th. Stern was Daisy James in the bar and Laura (recommended by Daisy James) in the dining room. These 3 people were very entertaining and really understood Engaged Hospitality .Thank you 3 and the team in the kitchen for a pleasant culinary experience! We will be back and look forward to all of you...."

##10 Pizza in Eureka

Details

#10 Pizza in Eureka