Paesello's Pizzeria - Goshen

What Kirk Miller likes about Paesello's Pizzeria:
My opinion is that it's the best pizza in town! Dollar for dollar, you can't really do better. There may be a cheaper 20 pizza, but you will get more meals out of Paesellos. For me, less is better. Pick one or two toppings, and request party square cuts. The crust is good. The cheese is good. The toppings are of good quality. My ONLY complaint... I wish they'd get rid of their Pandemic pick up window box. I'd like to... View all feedback.

What Baby Jules doesn't like about Paesello's Pizzeria:
We seem to always get a pretty good pizza when we order from here, but tonight we got an order of home fries and chicken strips with dipping barbecue sauce. The order of home fries? were a bunch of soggy looking and tough tasting, cold (maybe? potato chips and half way through the chicken strips I found what looks like the top of a bottle in the barbecue sauce. We were disappointed. Only saving grace is Teresa on the... View all feedback.