Papa Johns Pizza - Greencastle

The average rating of 3.5 shows that Papa Johns Pizza so far has satisfied the most of its guests.

What Bailey Halvorsen likes about Papa Johns Pizza:
Our order got delayed by a large order, we ordered online so we weren't able to be warned) and the staff handled it with such grace. They were not flustered and did not sacrifice quality. They simply kept us informed and apologized for our wait. Our pizzas were delicious and piping hot! View all feedback.

What Tylor Henning doesn't like about Papa Johns Pizza:
Ahamid took my order over the phone in a different country I go to pick it up there's 7 employees just standing at the register and none of them would help me they all just kind of wandered off and had the woman that was actually working come help me? Then I get home with my Philly pizza and it's a cheese pizza with peppers on it and 2 small pieces of meat! Not good service and would not recommend or try again! View all feedback.