Ye Olde Pizza Pub Reviews (158)

Reviews

At present, there are 158 assessments available from 5 website(s). The mean score for Ye Olde Pizza Pub is 3.3, implying that the restaurant is generally well received.

Overall Total Score

3.3 out of 5

Good | 158 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Sarah

10.08.2024 - 16:41

The Hamilton Pizza Pub is not that great anymore. The quality if the food is declining and the very small menu leaves a lot to be desired. The vibe is weird ins...

Wolfgang

10.08.2024 - 16:41

Don’t come here if you want slices because they don’t have

Kyle

10.08.2024 - 16:41

I used to go here a lot 10 years ago, and the pizza was awesome. Now the food was not as good, and it took a long time to get our order. I stopped in because of...

Gregory

10.08.2024 - 16:41

Literally done! I have enjoyed ye old my entire life so roughly 30 years. I wanted my 4 children to have the same experience and awesome memories. After the exp...

Toby

10.08.2024 - 16:41

Not what it used to be. I remember when you had to wait outside because the line was out the door to get a table. Now it looks like someone did a half professio...

Last update : 10.08.2024

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Hamilton

New York Pizzeria

4.8

City: Village of Waterville (near Hamilton), 111 West Main Street, Village Of Waterville, 13480, United States Of America, Village of Waterville

"Love this place, best pizza EVER! Frank and Rosa are amazing!"

#Pizza

Details

Pizza Pizzeria Cheese Pasta Chicken

Oliveri's Pizza

4.4

City: Hamilton, 14 Lebanon St, Hamilton I-13346-1104, United States

"Great food and great service!! Appreciate home delivery, too."

#Greek

Details

Greek Pizza Vegetarian Friendly

Bullthistle Brewing Company

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: Village of Sherburne (near Hamilton), 45 S Main St, Sherburne, NY, 13460, Village of Sherburne, United States

"Little place....big flavor! Every beer I had was outstanding"

#Breweries

Details

Breweries Delivery Services

Gilligan's Island

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Sherburne (near Hamilton), 64 N Main St, Sherburne, NY, 13460, United States

"Great ice cream! Can't go through Sherburne NY without stopping."

#American

Details

American Delivery Services

Rusch's Grill Open For In Dining Or Take Out

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: Melenki (near Hamilton), 22 Lebanon St, Hamilton, NY 13346, United States, Melenki, Russian Federation

"Sports bar! Lots of games on big screens. Had some good wings!"

#Grill

Details

Grill Cheese Sandwiches Pasta Meat

Joe's- Vinny's Pizzeria

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Sherburne (near Hamilton), 10 North Main Street, Village Of Sherburne, 13460, United States Of America

"Undercooked chicken wings. Pizza was sloppy overall bad food"

#Casual

Details

Casual Pizza Pizzeria Sandwiches

Michael's Fine Food Spirits

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Waterville (near Hamilton), 7674 US-20,NY 13480-2124, United States, Waterville

"Excellent food and atmosphere. they keep a beautiful rotation of special and seasonal beer. always good waiting staff and a delicious dinner. highly r..."

#American (New)

Details

American (New) American Seafood Pubs

Blue Canoe Grill

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: Erieville (near Hamilton), 3568 N Lake Rd, 13061, Erieville, United States

"This restaurant has excellent service and a great atmosphere."

#American

Details

American American (Traditional)

Colgate Inn Tap Room

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: New York (near Hamilton), 1 Payne Street, Hamilton, New York, 13346, United States

"I've been dining at the Inn for two years now in the summer, and honestly I don't understand what all the grousing is from Yelpers. We always enjoy ou..."

##8 Cafés in New York

Details

#8 Cafés in New York American