Reviews
The restaurant has received mixed reviews recently, with some customers expressing disappointment in the quality of the food and service. Complaints varied from cold pizza and subpar fettuccine Alfredo to small portions and tough chicken in the grilled chicken sandwich. Several reviewers mentioned changes in the size and taste of the dishes they had previously enjoyed. On the other hand, other customers raved about the delicious stuffed slice of pizza and the welcoming atmosphere of the pizzeria. The owners, identified as a large family, were praised for their friendly and attentive service. Overall, while some diners were let down by the recent experiences, others continued to support and enjoy the offerings of this family-owned establishment, generally, DeMarco's Pizza & Restaurant receives a rating of 4.2 on average.
Reviews from various websites
it recently renovated and it looks so much better and open. eating is still good. coming back when I am in west milford (hewitt).
Stopped in for a quick bite. Had a slice of sausage and pepper pizza and a Sicilian slice. Very good. Also got an Italian sub to go. Fresh and tasty. Owner was...
read moreDid this place change owners ? Ordered a bunch of stuff including a grilled chicken sandwich. Sandwich was 1/2 the size that they used to be and the chicken was...
read morelarge family owners, eating was fantastic what I can accept, the owner greeted me at the counter secured my friend and I got everything we needed (including foo...
read moreLive 8 minutes away waited over an hour and a half for a cold pizza. Dont prepay with card theyll take their sweet time, was considering them for my wifes baby...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreGreat family owned place, food was fantastic, what I can assume was the owner greeted me at the counter made sure my girlfriend and I got everything we needed (...
read moreWe love this place!!! Sicilian pizza is to die for! OMG! Our newest favorite!! Delicious! Crispy, cheesy and consistently cooked to perfection! Family owned whi...
read moreThey had remodeled the place since the last time. I've been there, but the ceiling is dirty, light burnt out. Is a c intake Vent filthy. And the pizza won't use...
read moreGreat food, excellent service, nice atmosphere. Love this place! Pizza was delicious.
I stopped in today and was pleasantly surprised to find a pizzeria owned by Italians. The environment was so communal, one of the patrons called the owner by th...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more