Reviews
Now, you have 173 opinions from 6 website(s) at your disposal. The midpoint review for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta is 2.4, denoting that this place was not among the favourites of some of its guests. Anthony's Pizza is a place where you can find excellent New York style pizza, despite some past disappointments with the cheese sticks and overall quality. Prices have risen, but the quality has not matched up. There have been issues with online orders not being delivered in full, and incorrect orders being received when dining in. The atmosphere in the restaurant has been described as unpleasant, with employees distracted and dismissive. However, the pizza itself has received praise for being a close match to New York-style pizza. Recent improvements have been noted, with cheesier slices, a cleaner restaurant, and larger portions. Despite some negative experiences, Anthony's Pizza is worth a try for those looking for a taste of New York in Colorado.
Reviews from various websites
My large cheese pizza was great. Also another time. Went in an hour before close on a slow day. Got Two slices. And they were fresh. Impressive for it being slo...
read moreAnthony’s Pizza is definitely improved since my last review. The slices of cheesier, the place is cleaner, and the person I complained about is no longer there....
read moreOrdered on line. Was ready on time. Pizza was delicious! Ordered 18 pepperoni, $34. Really enjoyed, it's been a long time since I have enjoyed a good pizza!
I placed an online order last week for delivery at our school for the kids in an after school program. Today some of the order was not delivered. I called askin...
read moreI like the food, and have gone to the Belleview store. I tried ordering on line several times but the order has been incorrect about 50% of the time. I decided...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreanthony is the place where I would refer people if they wanted an excellent NY pizza. the last couple of times the cheese sticks didn't taste good, so I didn't...
read morewhat else can they say? the whole menu is great I will always stop from anthony’s to have a great piece pizza
the biggest waste of $50 ever. order completely wrong. over $25 for a cheese pizza? who do they think they are? Unfortunately, dominos is a better choice.
my opinion after the best new yorker pizza in the opposite good crust, and if they like it more crispy only after extra crispy and they will cook it longer. goo...
read moreMy wife put in an online order at 5:00 pm, to be delivered at 7:00 pm. Our order did not arrive until 8:01 pm. This was after not one, but two calls to the stor...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more