Donato's - Mt Carmel Ave, Hamden

What Shawn Bortolan likes about Donato's:
Our intention was to get ice cream at Wentworths when we drove by Donato's. Thinking of having just a quick slice each, we gobbled up this wonderful new haven style pie (with no tang). Too bad we don't live anywhere close to this gem View all feedback.

What Chris D doesn't like about Donato's:
This location was formerly lots of other restaurants, none of them good. I stopped for quick lunch driving North on route 10 12:45PM. Only plain cheese was available by slices, so I ordered two along with can of Diet Coke. The slices were smaller than many, but the texture of the bread was almost un-chewable. The sauce was not very good and the cheese stingy .not much taste. In New Haven county, this was inexcusable. View all feedback.