Reviews
What Duncan Goldner doesn't like about Pie in the Sky Pizza:
We haven't ordered from here in a while, mostly because they are so expensive, but I wanted some of the honey jalapeño wings so we decided to order a pepperoni pizza too. Will never do it again. First, I think they must be under new ownership. The guy who answered the phone did not speak or understand English well so to order a medium pepperoni pizza light on the cheese, a side of extra pizza sauce, and boneless hone... View all feedback. What Rod Schaefer likes about Pie in the Sky Pizza:
I had the calzone....it was good, but not outstanding Prices seemed fair for a non chain"pizza place Don't come here for a date though. Main dining room was family friendly (ie most tables ha kids at them)....and it's small. The bar area may have been a better spot for me since I was found the single thing. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I would like to take a minute and complain. Me and my coworkers have been ordering pie in the sky lunch special to go for a couple of months. We were told it ha...
read moreOK??. Not a bad pizza but for the price...ehhh. I would certainly lower the price of a white pizza by five bucks, it's just cheese and sun dried tomatoes. Bar i...
read moreOther than the fact that we ordered a pizza that never came - our other food items were okay.
The food is very good, reallyTheir Spiral Breadstick is fantastic, and they use great ingredients (Especially their shaved sausage).
I'll skip the play by play but last visit 3 tables occupied in place, our order got destroyed coming out of the oven, they rushed a second pizza, manager
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreThis restaurant is known for its expensive yet delicious honey jalapeño wings, but recent experiences with the new ownership have left customers frustrated with communication issues and mistakes in their orders. While the pizza is good, some feel it's overpriced. The bartender lacks experience, and there seems to be a lack of overall staff training. Tips include requesting fresh bread with certain appetizers and being specific about drink orders. The calzone is decent, and prices are reasonable for a non-chain pizza place. The main dining room is family-friendly, while the bar area may be a better choice for a date night. Overall, the food and service are top-notch, with standout dishes like the BBQ Chicken Pizza and Greek Salad receiving high praise. Server Whitney is particularly highlighted for providing excellent service. Despite some issues, customers express a desire to return for more great food and service.