Brewsters Italian Cafe - New Buffalo

This restaurant is among the best in New Buffalo, within the category of Pizza, and based on the average assessment of 4.6, it's likely one of the favorite restaurants of its customers.

What Amiya Lueilwitz likes about Brewsters Italian Cafe:
Go To for Italian. Been going to Brewster's for over 10 years of consistently good meals. If you're a fan, don't skip their spinach and artichoke dip it's the best I've ever had. The thin crust pizzas are fantastic and they offer an array of great toppings. My favorite deal is the dinner for two, which is about $30 and includes a salad for each, a pizza to split, an entree to split, and coffee and cookies at the end... View all feedback.

What Trystan Wilkinson doesn't like about Brewsters Italian Cafe:
We ate at Brewster's this evening for my wife's 51st birthday. We were visiting from out of town, our first visit here in New Buffalo. First my wife was referred to as a guy while she does have short hair, she is very feminine looking. Our server seemed distracted, possibly too many tables, we had good service but her attention seemed elsewhere the whole time. I ordered shrimp Alfredo, it was alright, but all the shr... View all feedback.