Reviews
Menulist has collected all the evaluations for Pagley's Italian from various websites to give you a unbiased impression. Currently, there are 2030 evaluations from 4 website(s) available to you. The average rating for Pagley's Italian is 4.3 which means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help our visitors with your review for this restaurant!.
Reviews from various websites
All reviews for Pagley's Italian from all websites.
We love this place! It is our way to family favorites! The food is amazing and the staff is rocking!! We love Diane, Pat and Keith!
Great food and great people! They have the best ribeye anywhere!
Pagley’s us just outstanding. Worth the drive to New Castle.
We are very glad we found this place! Ribeye steak was out of this world! Portebella steak salad is amazing! Wedding soup is very good. The Cadillac flavored wi...
read moreGreat food! The best Italian food and the best steak I've ever eaten. Friendly staff and great service!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more