Sugar River Pizza Company Madison Reviews (422)

Reviews

Up to this point, you have 422 ratings from 3 website(s) on hand. The midpoint valuation for Sugar River Pizza Company Madison is 4.6, this indicates this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests.

Overall Total Score

4.6 out of 5

Outstanding | 422 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Absolutely amazing pizza, so many fresh ingredients, locally made cheese dough daily. What is not to love? When you put a dessert, her cheesecake is the best I'...

12.05.2023 - 17:21

The food is always great, and the staff is super friendly. We really enjoyed each other and ate too much!

12.05.2023 - 17:21

Great place to get a great pizza. Amazing selection of drinks included over 40 beers from 20 breweries. 15 special pizzas, as well as the possibility to build y...

12.05.2023 - 17:21

Handmade, fresh, absolutely delicious pizza!! Very impressed by everything we ordered! Pizza was amazing, even the wheat crust pizza was amazing!! Be proud of t...

12.05.2023 - 17:21

Always great pizza! Outdoor seating along the Sugar River trail is so relaxing. A must if you're visiting or traveling through New Glarus.

Last update : 12.05.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near New Glarus

Paoli Schoolhouse American Bistro

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Belleville (near New Glarus), 6857 Paoli RdWI 53508, Belleville, United States

"Maybe our dining room was very loud at a birthday party near us."

Farm To Table American

Fat Cat Coffee Works

4.6

Menu

4.6

Menu

City: New Glarus, 606 Railroad St, New Glarus I-53574-9538, United States

"Friendly staff! The best latte with a little white chocolate! Had yogurt there with fruit breakfast! My wife had the Quiche Caprese breakfast with Bas..."

##7 Cafés in New Glarus

#7 Cafés in New Glarus

Glarner Stube

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: New Glarus, 518 1st St, 53574, New Glarus, United States

"Great food! The first time all rose potatoes, meatballs and authentic fondue try. Excellent service! It jumped for a Thursday night."

##12 Fast Food in New Glar...

#12 Fast Food in New Glarus German

It's Time Grill Pub

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: Verona (near New Glarus), 608 W Verona Ave, 53593, United States

"Rail Bloody. Mary was 9.00. Food was ok"

##14 Cafés in Verona

#14 Cafés in Verona Seafood

Paoli Pub Grill

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: Belleville (near New Glarus), 6893 Paoli Rd, 53508, Belleville, United States

"The rating speaks for itself. Awesome!"

Grill Wine American Pub Kitchen Burgers

North And South Seafood Smokehouse

4.6

Menu

Table booking

4.6

Menu

Table booking

City: Verona (near New Glarus), 958 Liberty Dr, Verona I-53593, United States

"Excellent fraction, you also love the beans."

##1 Seafood in Verona

#1 Seafood in Verona American

Icki Sticki

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: Verona (near New Glarus), 103 S Main St, Verona I-53593-1419, United States

"Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##5 Cafés in Verona

#5 Cafés in Verona American

Sugar River Pizza Company

4.6

Menu

Table booking

4.6

Menu

Table booking

City: Verona (near New Glarus), 957 Liberty Dr, Verona I-53593-9319, United States

"Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##1 Vegetarian in Verona

#1 Vegetarian in Verona Pizza

Toot Kate's Wine

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: Madison (near New Glarus), 109 S Main St, Verona, WI 53593, United States, Madison

Street Parking, Outdoor Seating, Takeout, Parking area

Wine Cheese Drinks Pub Bars

Mcdonald's

4.2

Menu

Table booking

4.2

Menu

Table booking

City: Verona (near New Glarus), 107 Horizon Dr, 53593-1235, Verona, United States

"OK for a McDonalds. Has a good playland. But was kinda dirty."

##11 Fast Food in Verona

#11 Fast Food in Verona