Papa Joe's - New Hyde Park

So far, the Papa Joe's has received mixed reviews, which is reflected in the average evaluation of 2.7.

What Barry F likes about Papa Joe's:
I have eaten in at Papa Joe's several times over the years, as well as taken food out. The food is always of a high quality, and the sit down dining experience has always been outstanding as far as the service is concerned. Whenever I pass by Papa Joe's on Hillside I stop in for a meatball hero. The reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is that on occasion there has been a kid manning the front counter who was rather... View all feedback.

What David M doesn't like about Papa Joe's:
Stopped into this New Hyde Park pizzeria small Italian restaurant wanting to eat a Chicken Parmigiana Hero. It was good, not great. Actually, on the small side compared to other similar places. Bread was not an Italian loaf but a short Cuban Loaf. Odd. I even commented to the counter guy and he kinda just shrugged like its just the bread THE BREAD!!! THE BREAD!! ITS NOT ITALIAN BREAD!!! ITS ALL ABOUT THE BREAD!!! GEE... View all feedback.