Johnny's Pizza New Oxford Reviews (122)

Reviews

Currently, you have 122 appraisals from 5 website(s) on hand. The midpoint valuation for Johnny's Pizza New Oxford is 4.6, this indicates this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests.

Overall Total Score

4.6 out of 5

Outstanding | 122 reviews

Reviews from various websites

kevin-mejia-weed1440

01.11.2023 - 10:45

Didn’t know what to expect. We immediately felt their welcome. Their pepperoni pizza was amazing! Don’t get me started on their cheesesteak it was not normal ch...

01.11.2023 - 10:45

We take orders often. Good food and friendly

01.11.2023 - 10:45

This place is absolutely amazing I don’t know how people give bad reviews. Everything from pizza wings and Italian sub was on point. Absolutely amazing especial...

mike-botterbusch

01.11.2023 - 10:45

The best around for pizza n subs !!!Fresh made !!!

matthew-bryan-garcia

01.11.2023 - 10:45

Best place in New Oxford for pizza and subs... Hard contender with pizza garden but Johnny's won me.. I'm bearable prices

Last update : 01.11.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near New Oxford

Grillrilla

4.8

Menu

4.8

Menu

City: Hanover (near New Oxford), 1649 Broadway, Hanover I-17331-9606, United States

"Excellent food, reasonable prices, fast friendly service. Great !"

##25 Cafés in Hanover

#25 Cafés in Hanover Lunch Cheese

Half Pint Creamery

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: GETTYSBURG (near New Oxford), 1101 Biglerville Rd, Gettysburg I-17325-8554, United States, GETTYSBURG

"Lack of signage, had to guess how to get in store. OK ice cream."

American Ice Cream Chocolate Coffee

Cone Sweet Cone

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Gettysburg (near New Oxford), Cone Sweet Cone, 433 Baltimore St, Gettysburg, PA, 17325, USA, Afghanistan

"Ice cream was delicious yummy definitely coming back to visit.."

##29 Cafés in Gettysburg

#29 Cafés in Gettysburg American

Inn 94 Enterprises.

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: New Oxford, 4805 Carlisle Pike New Oxford, PA 17350-9738, United States

"I had bruised scallops, they were made perfect!"

French Food Delivery Services Seafood

Little Italy IV

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: New Oxford, 27 Stony Point Road New Oxford, PA 17350, United States

"Food is always delicious staff is friendly."

##7 Cafés in New Oxford

#7 Cafés in New Oxford Pizza Italian

Goofy's

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: Spring Grove (near New Oxford), 5965 York Rd, 17362, Spring Grove, US, United States

"Good eating, the owner's staff whitey is great?"

American Grill North American Pub

Crabbs Tropical Treats

4.6

Menu

4.6

Menu

City: Hanover (near New Oxford), 2279 Carlisle Pike, Hanover, PA, 17331, United States

"Price not read"

##39 Seafood in Hanover

#39 Seafood in Hanover American

Food 101

4.6

Menu

Table booking

4.6

Menu

Table booking

City: Gettysburg (near New Oxford), 18, 17325, Gettysburg, Afghanistan

"Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4"

##1 Fast Food in Gettysbur...

#1 Fast Food in Gettysburg

White Horse Diner

4.3

4.3

City: Thomasville (near New Oxford), 5408 Lincoln Hwy W, Thomasville I-17364-9515, United States

"Great food, service and atmosphere!!!"

##5 Cafés in Thomasville

#5 Cafés in Thomasville American

1863

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: GETTYSBURG (near New Oxford), 95 Presidential Cir, Gettysburg, USA, GETTYSBURG, United States

Television, Dogs Allowed, Outdoor Seating, Takeout

##4 Cafés in GETTYSBURG

#4 Cafés in GETTYSBURG American