Old Post Office Bagel Shop

The restaurant can be referred to as one of the favorites of its guests. This can be inferred from the average rating of 4.5, Furthermore, this joint is known as one of the best in New Shoreham, within the popular category Cafés.

What Nathan likes about Old Post Office Bagel Shop:
The best bagels I've ever eaten, they are second to none in my opinion. Great selection and everything is made fresh. I can't say enough good things about this place. View all feedback.

What Drew Jacob doesn't like about Old Post Office Bagel Shop:
Decent food and friendly staff, but the proprietor, Bill, enjoys being rude and confrontational with his customers. There are better breakfast options across the street at the Cracked Mug or around the corner at Persephone's. View all feedback.