Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackWithin the category Pizza, this place is considered one of the best in New Windsor, and based on the average rating of 4, Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Italian Eatery has so far greatly satisfied its guests.
What User likes about Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Italian Eatery:
best Italian place to go for deli and pizza. pizza always on point, excellent Italian sandwiches, actual philly style cheese steaks, and huge portions suppe that can feed like 3-4 people for $5. don't waste their time trying out places, just go here View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Italian Eatery:
Hands down one of the single worst pizzas in the area! Ordered a large pepperoni pie. It was greasy as hell. On top of that, their large is about the size of most place's small pie. Making matters worse, are their exorbitant prices.... the pizza, an over priced $8 app, and a bottle of water was $30!! Most expensive pizza in the area. Not worth the price, not even close. Will never go back and I suggest you stay away... View all feedback.
eat does not taste Italian. they need better cookmake real itailan eat . not eat threesome want to eat real italian
Thinnest slice around! but slice included odd aftertaste. Plus: Storefront requires you to wear a mask, but staff and pizza guy don’t wear them themselves.
Full Menu
The current list of dishes may be expanded on site to include seasonal specialties and weekly recommendations. In addition to a variety of meals, the card also offers a selection of beverages and typical house dishes. Additionally, the list of dishes also takes into account dishes and ingredients that have been commendably highlighted by customers, even if these have not yet been recorded.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
